3GS vs iP 4

[red-beard]

non contract 3GS 32GB is available for $199. Would this be a good entry level iPhone? My wife is looking to try one out.

I figure get this one, then if she really likes it, I'll get her the iP5 when it comes out. Is this a good strategy?

[RWebb]

usually a 2 year waiting period or a hefty charge to break that

be sure the contract has an upgrade provision

[craigster59]

I still like my 3GS. It does most everything the 4 does, I'm not in any hurry to upgrade.

[silverc4s]

I think the main difference between the 3 and the 4 is face time. Screen brightNess and battery life may also be better. If any of those are important to you, check out closer.

[gr8fl4porsche]

The 4 is also faster with a nicer screen.

I would just wait a few weeks and get the 5. She will love the iPhone.

Or, you could pick up a used 3GS for very cheap once the 5 is released.

Lots of folks that kept the 3GS and didn't go with the 4 are going to upgrade.

[nostatic]

I prefer the form factor of the 3GS (in fact I took back my android phone and am back on my original 3G) over the iP4. If you can believe the rumors the 5 will go back to that sleeker shape.

My 3G frankly is just on the edge of usability speed-wise, and it will not run the current iOS4 worth a damn and iOS5 won't even support the 3G (but will support the 3GS - whether it runs it fast enough remains to be seen).

[red-beard]

For $199, I went for it. Again, if she likes it, I'll get her the next gen when it comes out in a few months.

[porsche4life]

Ip5 is rumored to be released next week. In consumer hands by november...

[Rick Lee]

The day the iPhone 5 becomes available is the day I switch to Verizon. I'll be fine with a reduced-price iPhone 4. Wifey wants the 5. Hate AT&T. Gawd, I can't wait to leave them.

[Jeff Alton]

I almost chucked my 3GS into the ocean, my 4 has not caused me any problems yet...