Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/)
-   Porsche 911 Technical Forum (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/porsche-911-technical-forum/)
-   -   why disconnect the O2 sensor? (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/porsche-911-technical-forum/137062-why-disconnect-o2-sensor.html)

dvkk 11-24-2003 10:58 AM

why disconnect the O2 sensor?
 
Why does everyone here disconnect their O2 sensor? Is there a perception of more hp? My understanding of FI is that they all go to a rich condition at WOT, so that can't be it.
Is it that you are all trying to pollute more? You enjoy failing your state smog inspection?

CarreraS2 11-24-2003 11:04 AM

Do everyone really disconnect their O2 sensors here? I've never noticed that.

On a CIS car, I suppose it would give one more control over the mixture. You wouldn't have the Lambda box constantly correcting it.

On a Motronic car, I don't think there would be much advantage. It seems that if disconnected, it defaults to a rich position, which probably isn't optimal. On the BMW list, a lot of guys with the older Motronic cars seem to disconnect 02 sensors as a "Band Aid" to get their cars to run better. Like the car has vacuum leaks or other problems, and disconnecting the O2 makes it run a lot richer, which smoothes out the idle and "fixes" other running problems.

Superman 11-24-2003 11:08 AM

My CIS system will make the mixture REALLY LEAN at idle, if you let it. Unplugging the O2 sensor prevents this. I believe that this does not affect the mixture at other engine speeds, WOT, etc. It's just a really really lean condition at idle. Like .8% versus 3.5%. Since disconnecting he O2 sensor, my spark plugs are not nearly as white.

UTKarmann_Ghia 11-24-2003 11:12 AM

Mine was disconnected when I bought the car. Being the ambitious guy I am, I decided to put in a new one and hook it up. I even had the mixture adjusted by the local Porsche wrench, but it made my car run VERY VERY HOT (once to 270). When I finally figured it out, I yanked that sucker never to be seen or heard from again.

sue me...

dvkk 11-24-2003 11:13 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Superman
My CIS system will make the mixture REALLY LEAN at idle, if you let it. Unplugging the O2 sensor prevents this. I believe that this does not affect the mixture at other engine speeds, WOT, etc. It's just a really really lean condition at idle. Like .8% versus 3.5%. Since disconnecting he O2 sensor, my spark plugs are not nearly as white.
I wouldn't call .8% "really lean". Why do you care what the mixture is when your foot is off the throttle?

Vipergrün 11-24-2003 11:32 AM

dvkk, most of us who have removed/disconnected the O2 sensor have done so in conjuntion with other changes. These include setting timing to more advance and purposefully richening the mixture. The O2 sensor will try to keep the mixture lean. BTW, I just passed CA smog without an O2 sensor OR a cat (mine was gutted). As far as pollution, if you want to go on the attack, try the H2, Excursion, Suburban boards.....

VaSteve 11-24-2003 11:33 AM

Since I'm still waiting on some books and such, can one of you supply a photo of where the O2 sensor is, so I can check on it?
Thanks
Steve

Vipergrün 11-24-2003 11:35 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by VaSteve
Since I'm still waiting on some books and such, can one of you supply a photo of where the O2 sensor is, so I can check on it?
Thanks
Steve

Steve, take a peek behind the rear driver side wheel. You should see the O2 sensor in the catalytic converter. It *should* have a wire coming from it which goes into the engine compartment.

-B

Tim Walsh 11-24-2003 11:39 AM

Steve,
I had this exhaust system on my T when I first bought it. Here's a pic.
http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...20abovejpg.jpg

Superman 11-24-2003 11:39 AM

My mixture is perfect. The dyno guy was the most recent to make this observation. It is more than FOUR TIMES the richness of emission spec (0.8%). I'd say that's lean. Emissions regulations in 1983 required that this super-lean mixture be achieved at idle. So, this spec was designed to please not engineers or mechanics or engines or owners, but emissions technicians. I don't meet any emissions technicians, so without the opportunity to impress them, I'm just going with what is most pleasing to engines, engineers, etc.

Perhaps my CIS system would lean this mixture during steady-throttle cruising. In that case, there'd be detonation from the moment I mashed the throttle until the moment the switch told the computer that I intend to accelerate. That's just wrong. Emissions spec is not the "right" mixture. These engines get away with it for the most part, but it is the "wrong" mixture for engine health.

besides, I like the smell. Rich mixture smell beats rotten eggs every time.

VaSteve 11-24-2003 11:40 AM

Tim,
The orange thingy to the right of the red shock?
You come through again, man!
Steve

VaSteve 11-24-2003 11:51 AM

Of course, I just went out and checked and it appeared to be plugged in. I could only test by feeling, since there's a shield in the way.

Back to the drawing board. :(

stlrj 11-24-2003 11:51 AM

Most often the 02 sensor is disconnected out of ignorance and the lack of skill to set up the injection system to make it work the way that it was designed.

So the fast and stupid solution is to disconnect it.

Cheers,

Joe Garcia
86 Carrera
Redwood PCA since 1976 ( former tech chair)
Building systems engineer
Automotive Computer Controls Technician

Tim Walsh 11-24-2003 11:59 AM

steve,
yes that orange thing is the shock. It's a koni. There's a little bung to the right that's the o2 sensor.

chuckr 11-24-2003 12:01 PM

Most often the 02 sensor is disconnected out of ignorance and the lack of skill to set up the injection system to make it work the way that it was designed.

So the fast and stupid solution is to disconnect it.

.... with statements like this, no wonder your are FORMER tech chair

VaSteve 11-24-2003 12:14 PM

No, no. I meant this thing in the circle. (It's kinda orange too...)

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1069708481.jpg

stlrj 11-24-2003 12:21 PM

Sorry if you are offended by this, but it was not intended to offend anyone as I would be the first to admit my ignorance and stupidity on more than I would like to admit.

Having been on both sides of the fence, I can recognize ignorance when I seez it.

Joe

KFC911 11-24-2003 12:36 PM

Steve, on my 3.2, the O2 sensor looks quite a bit different that the one on Tim's car (and I'm guessing that your SC is probably more similar to mine). Although it isn't a 'clear' shot of the O2 sensor, the following pic shows mine (approx. 2 1/2" tall). I've also got a euro premuffler which replace the cat.

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1069709781.jpg

jester911 11-24-2003 12:38 PM

That is a pic of the sensor, but Steve you need to look in the engine bay to see if it is plugged in.

Look on the left side down at the bottom of the bay the wire comes through the metal next to the wheel well it has a connector
that may or may not be plugged in.

KFC911 11-24-2003 12:40 PM

Here's a smaller resolution (and I'm practicing posting pics :)!):



http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1069710050.jpg

edited...why do my pics appear as a link instead of the actual pic?

KFC911 11-24-2003 12:45 PM

One more try:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1069710336.jpg

Tim Walsh 11-24-2003 12:49 PM

Keith,
Try using only alphanumeric filenames. spaces and "(" screw it up.

That is the O2 sensor on my engine but I have no clue what it's from (SC or 3.2). It's also no longer on the engine since MFI has no use for the O2 sensor.

ruf-porsche 11-24-2003 01:10 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by stlrj

The fast and the stupid .......

Sound like a nice movie title for next year car flick for the summer.

JackT 11-24-2003 01:38 PM

So does disconnecting make the car faster?

Superman 11-24-2003 01:57 PM

No.

1fastredsc 11-24-2003 02:20 PM

No power increase, it's more of an issue of longevity to the engine. When running that lean with an o2 sensor hooked up, you can shorten the life of an air cooled motor. I don't speak for all of them, but i believe the sc originally wasn't designed for emission stuff, just had it slapped on. This is why we get such a large power gain from getting rid of the emission stuff and backdating the exhaust. As far as polluting, we are kind of a select crowd, there aren't many air cooled enthusiasts on the road. Now for a water cooled motor that has better control of it's head temps to not run a cat is plain ignorance. Besides, having your car tuned properly and having constant attention is a bigger factor in passing the smog nazi test than anything else.

VaSteve 11-24-2003 02:29 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by 1fastredsc
No power increase, it's more of an issue of longevity to the engine. When running that lean with an o2 sensor hooked up, you can shorten the life of an air cooled motor. I don't speak for all of them, but i believe the sc originally wasn't designed for emission stuff, just had it slapped on. This is why we get such a large power gain from getting rid of the emission stuff and backdating the exhaust. As far as polluting, we are kind of a select crowd, there aren't many air cooled enthusiasts on the road. Now for a water cooled motor that has better control of it's head temps to not run a cat is plain ignorance. Besides, having your car tuned properly and having constant attention is a bigger factor in passing the smog nazi test than anything else.
By the SC series, ho wcould it *not* be designed for emissions stuff? It had been in place for a while at that point. Wasn't it the 74-77's that suffered all the pulled head studs and what not as a result of hotter temps due to emissions?

stlrj 11-24-2003 02:59 PM

Yeh... and all the bulletproof air cooled 911's run 02 sensors with the 78/79 SCs as the only exceptions...how do you explain that?


Joe

911nut 11-24-2003 03:03 PM

I beg to differ.........
 
At an air-fuel ratio of 14.7/1 you get maximum efficiency (MPG) and lowest emmisions. At an air/fuel ratio of 12.5/1 you get maximum torque. If anyone doesn't believe me it's all in Posbt's book on CIS. Look it up.
Disconnecting your O2 sensor and resetting the idle mixture to 3-3.5% CO gives the engine a real kick in the pants. My car really came to life after I did this. Also, part throttle, low speed operation is improved as you get rid of the surging caused by the frequency valve playing with the fuel pressure in the fuel distributor. Also, the car will idle smoother for the same reason.
Call me stupid if you like but I prefer a powerful, good running car instead of a EPA-castrated transportation device.

stlrj 11-24-2003 03:18 PM

Quote:

resetting the idle mixture to 3-3.5% CO gives the engine a real kick
Paul, were your readings before or after the cat?

What were your CO readings when you where having all the surging with the 02 sensor connected? Was it set to spec, less than 0.8% CO taken ahead of the cat? If not, that could have been your problem.

Joe

slakjaw 11-24-2003 05:12 PM

when you unplug the o2 sensor it goes to .440, you can measure the voltage at the plug it will be around .440. this is not rich not lean, kinda in the middle.

also, the o2 sensor is absolutely useless at idle, they are designed to work at 2000 rpm or more. unpluging it should make no diffrence in idle quality unless there are other problems with the fuel or iginition system.

also, once you pass 80% throttle the computer will give the motor a set value of 12:1 or even 10:1 air fuel ratio. at that point it dosent even care what the o2 is seeing. so i dont under stand how unpluging it could give much more power.

i have the flu and just worked a 12 hour day so maybe i am just out of my mind right now.

Kyle

911nut 11-24-2003 06:46 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by stlrj
Paul, were your readings before or after the cat?

What were your CO readings when you where having all the surging with the 02 sensor connected? Was it set to spec, less than 0.8% CO taken ahead of the cat? If not, that could have been your problem.

Joe

I have no cat, just a test pipe.
The CO reading was at .8% prior to my tweeking it.
When I say surge, I mean a slight surge, actually a "lope". It happens at low speed (25-30 MPH) and it's the result of the frequency valve doing it's job (when the O2 sensor is hooked up).

911nut 11-24-2003 06:58 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by slakjaw

also, the o2 sensor is absolutely useless at idle, they are designed to work at 2000 rpm or more. unpluging it should make no diffrence in idle quality unless there are other problems with the fuel or iginition system.

also, once you pass 80% throttle the computer will give the motor a set value of 12:1 or even 10:1 air fuel ratio. at that point it dosent even care what the o2 is seeing. so i dont under stand how unpluging it could give much more power.

Kyle

The K-lambda CIS is designed to yield 14.7/1 A-F ratio at all throttle settings other than WOT to keep the cat from being overwhelmed. Unpluging the O2 sensor and turning the set screw changes the relationship between the air sensor plate and the piston inthe fuel distributor. Exposing more of the metering slits on the piston for a given air flow will enrich the mixture. At all throttle positions other than WOT there will be more torque.
The k-lambda computer will vary mixture even at idle. It's the constant overshooting of the control system that causes the uneven idle.

Lorenfb 11-24-2003 10:20 PM

911nut provided the most accurate comments about the O2 sensor. Once
disconnected on either a K-Lambda or Motronic, the mixture setting should
go the neutral mode (about .50 volts input). Here the CO setting can be made
before the CAT. Ideally the setting is about 1.5% up to maybe 2.5% to 3.0%.
This will give the best overall performance. A much higher value can possibly
damage the CAT.

Once the O2 sensor is connected, the CO should come down to less than .5%.
Under hard accel, e.g. full throttle, both systems ignore the O2 sensor. The
K-Lambda system utilizes an enrichment relay for additional fuel. Check out
this website (www.systemsc.com) on the Technical & Graphs pages for some
additional info.

Have Fun
Loren
'88 3.2

sammyg2 11-25-2003 06:22 AM

My SC passed smog just fine two years ago with the O2 sensor disconnected, and that was in So Cal on a roller dyno test.
That means that disconnecting the O2 sensor does not necessarily result in more pollution.

I have the O2 sensor hooked up now and it does cause a very slight modulation in power at cruising speed.

CIS is just not accurate enough to control the air/fuel mixture at exactly 14.7 to 1 throughout the entire range of operation. The lambda system tries to make it more accurate but this can cause some swinging from overcompensation. My O2 sensor reads either rich or lean, nothing inbetween. It is this switching back and forth which causes some modulation. A very small change in the lambda reading makes a significant change in HC.
The early SCs did not have an O2 sensor. The lambda system was an add on to the existing system in an attempt to meet ever tightening regulations under certain operating temperatures and conditions.

By disconnecting it some folks can set it where they want it and get rid of the very slight surging that many KE-Jet cars seem to have at steady cruise.
I could keep making adjustments until I nail the mixture just right at steady cruising speed, but chances are I would have to compromise on the ideal mixture setting at some other operating condition.
Does that make me ignorant? I don't think so. Does it mean my CIS system may not be operating quite as well as when it rolled off the showroom floor? Of course it does. It's 24 years old.
I may eventually get it perfect if I throw enough money at it, or I may just leave it where it runs well and I'm happy with it and just go drive it.

1fastredsc 11-25-2003 06:41 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by stlrj
Yeh... and all the bulletproof air cooled 911's run 02 sensors with the 78/79 SCs as the only exceptions...how do you explain that?


Joe

That's not totally fair, especially since before 78 the 911 motors had mag cases which are the main reason as the why the studs can pull. Well that and from what i hear, the thermal reactors.
911 nut is also right, 12.5 is where peak torque is acheived. With the o2 sensor hooked up, 14.7 will always be the goal fuel mixture.
As far as the design, the optimal design for an NA exhaust system is to have equal length headers which with the sc and carrera aren't possible because of the wonderful heat radiating cat by the left bank of cylinders.
And as said before, taking care of your engine is much more important to "pollution" than having a cat strapped to the exhaust. I had a 944 hollowed out cat pass emission in NJ with no problems, but a nissan pickup flunk with a brand new factory cat. Turned out that giving it a good tune up and running some heavy duty injector cleaner through it is what passed it, not the new cat.

wanabe911 owner 10-06-2004 04:01 PM

Found mine disconnected?
 
Do I connect or leave alone, I have only owned the car for a month. Idle hunts until it warms up, sometimes will shut down when getting off the gas and on the brake like pulling to a stop. I have fixed a few obvious vacume leaks.

Thack 10-06-2004 05:30 PM

The lambda control unit is designed to cycle the freq. valve at a certain duty cycle when the O2 sensor is unhooked. So you can unhook the O2 sensor and the ECU will not adjust the mixture. That is why you can adjust your mixture at idle while warm and be close for most throttle openings. Also the O2 cannot tell the ECU what to do untill the warm up switch reaches about 350* C. The O2 sensor can adjust your mixture for altitude. It is really a good system when adjusted properly. The ECU is really an add-on for the 1979 CA models and the 1980. It actually came from the 924 Turbo and was not really designed for the 911. Maybe that is why it is not perfect.

Mike

Thack 10-06-2004 05:35 PM

Correction, the O2 sensor must reach 350* C. The temp switch warms up and then lets the ECU adjust mixture at a certain temp value. I assume close to the same time when the O2 sensor reaches 350* C.

wanabe911 owner 10-07-2004 05:43 AM

Connected 02 last night, results
 
So I connected the 02 sensor last night, no change at first, then when the car warmed up, two things happened. 1 the engine quit stumbling when I get off the gas to slow to a stop. 2 My hesitation problem started again! A little background about a month ago I took my car to a local service center, Vertex Miami (just purchased) to sort out a few issues, one of which was that the car would no smoothly accelerate from a standing start, once past 3000-3500 RPM's or at WOT it would take off. So he had it for a month, changed injectors, checked AFM, compression, and fixed quite a few vac leaks. Said he could not get rid of the hesitation. So I told him I would pick it up. I really wanted the car back, so I drove the car, they had it warmed up, and the hesitation was gone, but it never shut off on me. So I took it home, on the way home every single time, I would slow to a stop (off the gas on the brake) it either stumbled, or shut off completely. Sorry about the ramble. Any ideas on what I should do next.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:00 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.