Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/)
-   Porsche 911 Technical Forum (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/porsche-911-technical-forum/)
-   -   930 WUR - Pressure Test Complete (Pix), Perplexing Results (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/porsche-911-technical-forum/218647-930-wur-pressure-test-complete-pix-perplexing-results.html)

RarlyL8 04-27-2005 06:50 PM

930 WUR - Pressure Test Complete (Pix), Perplexing Results
 
To any who have been following my CIS issues. Background:

- Hard start cold. Cranks for 30+ seconds then chuggs to life.
- Lean mixture readings cold and warm. A/F ~ 16:1 CO ~ 0.0%
- Runs perfect and has the proper mixture on boost, A/F 12.5:1

This condition came on gradually over a few months. Symptoms were a slow start of several seconds accompanied by steady increase of cruezing A/F ratio from 14:1 to 15:1. All crashed to present condition in one weekend.

Here are the Pressure Readings:

COLD - 1.5 bar (20psi)
WARM - 3.2 bar
SYSTEM - 5.7 bar
BLEED - 1.6 bar held for 20+ minutes

These readings are within spec. WHAT THE HECK IS GOING ON?

My mechanic swears it is the WUR. How can this be when all seems to be working as it should? Are the readings close enough to being off-spec that they would cause this condition?

(Jim, expect a call Thursday. HA!)




http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1114656651.jpg

gsxrken 04-27-2005 07:56 PM

How about vacuum leaks around the intake or the intercooler?

ianc 04-27-2005 07:58 PM

Sorry, I didn't follow your other thread, but...

CSV and AAV working properly? Those are the two biggest culprits for hard cold starts...

ianc

mmastro 04-28-2005 06:53 AM

I had a similar problem (hard start, but irratic idle) and went through the WUR testing and was confused by the results. I checked the prices for a WUR for a Euro 3.0L 930 ($$$$!) and decided to check the vacuum hoses for problems. I replaced the cracked distributor vac line and discovered another vac line was pinched under the left lower intercooler mount. Fixed that and all was fine. Just a thought.

RarlyL8 04-28-2005 08:45 AM

I have eyeballed the vacuum lines and all apear sound. They will all be replaced soon if this issue persists.

My CIS is extremely minimalistic. Only the fuel head, WUR, and cold start valve remain. All other components were removed when the engine was rebuilt 2 years ago.
You'd think only 3 components would be easy to diagnose.

ewave 04-28-2005 08:59 AM

How old are the ignition wires and plugs?

ianc 04-28-2005 09:07 AM

This might be a silly question, but why were the other components removed? They're there for a reason...

The lack of an AAR, AAV will decrease starting\cold running performance...

ianc

RarlyL8 04-28-2005 07:36 PM

No, those parts aren't needed. When I left Illinois they left the car.
You only need the AAV and AAR if you live in a cold region or don't like to hold the throttle for a few moments after start up. Remember those 2 items do not function until AFTER the engine starts. That is the beauty of CIS, being a component system.

This engine has run PERFECTLY in its minimalistic form sense the rebuild.

Good idea on the wires, I don't know how old they are. They are braided steel sleaved like OEM. The plugs are also 2 years old. The CIS components are all original. I took the entire system apart during the rebuild, cleaned and inspected everything. Fuel head was interesting.....

I'm sending a used WUR that I bought from a fellow PelicanHead off to be rebuilt. We will see how that turns out. In the mean time I'll do as all of you have suggested and look into other possible reasons for the problem. I'll look into each area one at a time using the existing WUR so as not to change the baseline.

ianc 04-28-2005 08:10 PM

Quote:

You only need the AAV and AAR if you live in a cold region or don't like to hold the throttle for a few moments after start up. Remember those 2 items do not function until AFTER the engine starts. That is the beauty of CIS, being a component system.
Not true. The AAV is there solely to provide extra air at startup. It closes and does not reopen as long as the engine is running. The AAR also supplies extra air at startup and during warmup until the bimetal in it closes the valve.

ianc

RarlyL8 04-29-2005 04:06 AM

I know what they do, you don't need extra air until AFTER you start the engine. You get the same result if you crack the throttle with your foot. Early CIS cars had a hand throttle for this function.

Trust me, I've been driving this car in all types of temperatures for 10 years. You don't need all that crap. Most of it was emmision related.

Crowbob 04-29-2005 06:15 AM

Rarly,

I want to clean up my engine and get rid of all that stuff and go minimalist. Are there some step-bystep instructions available somewhere to accomplish this?

Jim

Porsche_monkey 04-29-2005 06:43 AM

Why not do a propane or acetylene vacuum leak test?

Paulporsche 04-29-2005 06:51 AM

JW has said that the mixture screw has a lot more impact @ idle than @ higher revs. Since your WUR function seems fine and your A/F is fine @ WOT, but your CO is 0.0% @ idle, why not try richening your mixture @ idle and see what happens? Maybe you will be as rich as reqd for start and warmup, yet still be OK for boost.

Porsche_monkey 04-29-2005 06:51 AM

Now the right guy is on the job...

john walker's workshop 04-29-2005 07:20 AM

sounds like either the hot idle mix needs to be richened, which also makes the cold running richer by adding to what the WUR is supposed to do when it's cold, or the WUR needs to be richened to run the engine nicely when cold. is the 930 engine lambda equipped, or not? either way, i tend to leave the oxy sensor unplugged and set the hot idle mix to as much as 4% on 930s. there also was a thermo-valve originally, that kept the vacuum retard from operating for a minute or so, which kept the idle up.

RarlyL8 04-29-2005 08:16 AM

Paul - one of the original symptoms was a slight occillation at idle when warm, about 300rpm. Because I adjust the mixture seasonally and it is spring I tweeked it lean. When I put it back the occillations went wild, a typical response to a rich condition. The CO reading at that point was off scale 0%. You cannot richen the mixture warm.

John - the mixture, both cold and warm, needs to be more rich. The engine is a 930/63 modded and does not have a Lambda system, K-jetronic only. When the engine was rebuilt a little over 2 years ago I set it at 3% CO. It remained rock steady until a couple of months ago.

To me, it appears that the WUR is fighting itself and the Fuel Distributor with the result being an occillation at idle.

Another unusual symptom, now that the mixture has been set an 1/8 turn lean to releave the occillation, is that the idle is higher. It was 1000rpm before, now it is 1300rpm.

Jim - I don't know of any step-by-step instructions. You need to evaluate the real-world use of your car, the weather in your region, and your love/hate for gadgets that do things like raise the idle for you. In Northern Michigan you may not wish to eliminate much if any of the system.

John - Do you know/use anyone who rebuilds WURs? I have contacted an outfit called Fuel Injection Corporation in Livermore CA. Know anything about them?

ianc 04-29-2005 09:27 AM

Why not just modify the WUR yourself to make it adjustable? Being able to set it to a variety of settings might help to compensate some for the missing bits, or whatever else is freaky.

ianc

RarlyL8 04-29-2005 02:00 PM

My WUR is adjustable. I have tried to compensate and have achieved a little improvement. Right now it looks like I'll wait for the rebuilt unit to arrive (next week). That should tell me something.

Paulporsche 04-29-2005 02:39 PM

RarlyL8,

Just a few more thoughts.

Are you sure your CO gauge is correct? 0.0% sounds very odd.
1/8 turn is about 1%, maybe even 1.5%. Can you just nudge that screw in smaller increments? That's what I typically do.

Haxe you checked your sensor plate to make sure it is moving freely and not hanging up or weighted down by grease, etc? I think you mentioned you have already checked for air leaks. I see you still have a decel valve. Did you check that? I assume you have already checked distributor, timing, plugs, wires and all 7 injectors.

I find that is not unusual at all for the idle speed to change w/ the mixture setting. When the mix is leaned I always have to lower the revs.

Why do you say the mixture cannot be adjusted when warm? I don't understand that.

My Bentley manual says the AAV adds bypass air while starting only. The AAR adds bypass air during warmup only.

Your CCP was just a little low. if you were @ 10C. At what temp did you measure it?

I am wondering if your bimetal strip is shot in the WUR or maybe the relationship between the cold and warm settings is off. This can be changed by adjusting a screw on the bottom of some WURs.

What color is the inside of your tailpipe? I find on my car, the richness of the mix definitely changes the shade of it...leaner=brownish; richer=blackish. This is w/ Sunoco 94. I have noticed over the years, however, that tailpipes of turbos are quite often quite a bit lighter than NA cars.

ianc 04-29-2005 03:51 PM

Quote:

My Bentley manual says the AAV adds bypass air while starting only. The AAV adds bypass air during warmup only.
Yes, the AAV is only open during startup, and is meant to add extra air. As soon as the engine develops any appreciable vacuum, it closes. The AAR (which is what I think you meant in the second part of your statement) will also add extra air at start because it's open at that point. It doesn't shut until it warms up.

In my experience, the thing that really kills the startup is the cold start valve not working for some reason, so I'd investigate that first. Is the thermotime switch working (measure resistance cold and warm)? Are the wires connected to it hooked up the right way? It DOES make a difference if the connections are on backwards. Is the CSV acually shooting gas? Hook up your pressure gauge and look for a press drop when you jump the CSV.

Even on a mild CA summer day, if the CSV is not working, you can crank the thing forever from cold and it won't start...

ianc

Paulporsche 04-29-2005 05:47 PM

Thanks, ianc. edited to AAR, and 7 injectors.

oneblueyedog 04-29-2005 07:12 PM

when I went through my cis on my SC, I took the unit off of the airbox to replace the foam cushion perimeter gasket. I cleaned off the varnish from the sensor plate and even removed the peg from the fuel distributor ( the thing you're not supposed to drop ). I noticed that the peg was machined on most of its perimeter but it also had some mirror polished wear marks in a certain orientation. I reassembled it not paying attention to the wear marks. When I started it back up it idled horribly and I spent a couple of nights checking pressures and such. I then remembered the polished peg. I checked the sensor plate and found it did not fall back easily after lifting it. I then rotated the peg with my fingetips until it rebounded back with ease. It started right up and has worked fine ever since.

THe peg must lap into the fuel distributor or wear in after 25+ years. I have no idea if this could be a similar problem in your 930 but I though I might share it with you. I imagine when you buy a rebuilt fuel distributor this is an important part they remanufacture.

If I ever have to get a fuel dist. It's Megasquirt time insread.

RarlyL8 04-29-2005 08:09 PM

Paul -
1) Gunson Gas Tester checks out OK. Steady baseline of 2.0% until you stick it up the pipe. Divebombs to 0.0%. A/F meter verifies.
2) I have fine-tuned the mixture to a point where it no longer occillates. It does respond well within that range.
3) Sensor plate was taken apart and cleaned when the engine was rebuilt. It still looks good today. No issues I can see.
4) The decel valve was left in place to ease transition of off-throttle events. I have no idea if it is worth keeping or if it in fact works at all.
5) I see no need to check the ignition. The car runs perfectly once started. It has a lean mixture off-boost. All symptoms tell me this is an air/fuel issue.
6) The idle has increased 300rpm. That is consistant with your lean mixture characteristic.
7) The mixture cannot be adjusted warm because it begins to occillate before the desired settings are met. So it probably can be set but it will occillate from 600-1600rpms if you attempt it.
8) You are correct in the functions of the AAV and AAR, however I have none of these devices on my engine.
9) I measured the CCP @ 65F.
10) I believe 100% that the bi-metal strip has failed. What puzzles me are the Pressure readings. They are not significantly out of spec. Could it be that the A/F ratio tells more to this story than the fuel pressure?
I don't beleive my WUR has an adjustment screw on the bottom, only the top (and it is not responding very well).
11) The inside of the tailpipe is black from the soot of fire. ;)

Ianc-
1) You are correct in the function of the AA devices but again, they don't exist on my engine.
2) The cold start valve was my first guess a few months ago when the first symptoms occured. I have eliminated that as a possibility because of the lean condition that persists during off-boost driving. As you know the cold start valve has no function after the engine starts. The hard starts don't bother me, they are only an anoyance. The lean condition does bother me.
3) There were 2 thermo time devices on the original 930/63 engine. They no longer exist.
4) The car should not start at all if the Cold Start Valve has failed. If I artificially alter the control pressure with the adjustment screw on the WUR the car will fire up in just a few seconds. This leads me to beleive that the CSV is fine. Unfortunately there is not enough adjustment to eleviate the lean running condition.

I get the feeling that some folks either don't understand or cannot beleive that you can run and drive a CIS car every day with only a fuel distributor, WUR, and Cold Start Injector. These components truely are all you need, no, they are the only components you MUST HAVE. That is not to say that an AAV might not make life easier if you live in Canada but you get the idea.

Thank you both for your questions. I've had to re-visit all of my notes made when I first put this beast together. I remember thinking to myself back then "wonder how long this old fuel injection junk will last?" Guess I got my answer.

Paulporsche 04-30-2005 11:49 AM

RarlyL8,

It sure sounds like you have gone through a very thorough exam!

Your CCP is low. I think it should be about 1.9 to about 2.4 bar @ 65F. You said you were 1.5 bar. I think this could account for some of the issues. That's about 6 to 13 psi too low on a range of about 28 to 36 psi.

I don't know if you sent your existing WUR off to be rebuilt yet, but if not, look @ the underside. Often there is a brass plug there. It can be removed and a screw found within can be adjusted. This changes the relationship between the cold and warm CP. Even if the plug isn't there you could still open the unit up and make the adjustment, or perhaps drill it out to access it. If you search, I think I remember a thread or at least a response from JW on this procedure.

Regarding the decel valve: usually the older style fails, allowing a vac leak to occur. Often people bypass the problem by plugging the top line. I honestly don't know if this is appropriate for your style.

Also, have you measured the resistance on the bimetallic strip? There was a recent thread on WUR adjustment where the resistance was given. Was it 18 - 22 ohms?

I am leaning to either the wrong relationship between the CCP and WCP, or the strip.

If you do not want to tackle either of these procedures, then sending it to an expert is obviously best. If that's what you finally do, please let us know what they did and what it cost you.

BTW I am not one of those who feels you must have an AAR and/or AAV, especially in AL. I was just addressing some questions/ comments raised by others regarding those items. Do you start the car w/ the accelerator pressed down? If so, how far? And for warmup, do you do the same?

And, regarding service life of these components: 27 yr or so ain't too bad!

RarlyL8 04-30-2005 08:11 PM

After re-reading my old notes and these new posts I decided to test the WUR again this morning. The pressure tests came out identical. I then concentrated on the bi-metalic strip. Nowhere in my factory manuals or CIS manuals could I find where it states how long it should take for the pressure to raise once the ignition is cranking. I timed this event 3 times with extremely consistant results. The bi-metal strip is working. It takes 3 minutes to acheive and hold peak pressure. Is this 3 minutes correct?
All the data on the WUR tells me it is indeed working. Not perfect but probably not off-spec enough to cause the issues at hand.

SO it is time to look at other things. I'm not going to ignore the WUR but other things need checked. As you guys have pointed out, the only other system that could cause a lean condition and hard start is a massive vacuum leak. I have very few vacuum lines on this engine so they shouldn't be hard to check. The Fuel Distributor is next if I find no leaks.

Paul - I've feilded many e-mails questioning me on minimalistic CIS. This system was stripped when I lived in Illinois, very cold place in the winter. The only component I used in IL that I removed in AL is the AAV. I used it as a convenience item in IL, it became a PITA in AL by revving too high for my taste on initial start up in warm weather.
The method I use to start the car, even in the winter, is to get in and crank the ignition with NO throttle until the engine starts. Once the engine starts I give it throttle to 2000rpm and hold it for 30 seconds. That's it. If it's really cold you feather the throttle at stoplights until she warms up.

About the Fuel Head. I restored that unit whith the rest of the CIS stuff shortly after I purchased the engine. It was siezed up. The motor was a theft recovery with no history. Don't know how long it had been sitting with bad gas in it. Anyway, I took the fuel head apart and saoked the fuel cylinder with carb cleaner for about 2 weeks until the piston fell out on its own. I then carefully cleaned everything and put it back together. You're right about the extreme tolerances. These items are a machine matched set. Drop the piston you might as well throw the hole thing away.

Stay tuned for an update on Sunday. I plan to rip off the rest of the CIS system and check each vacuum hose thoroughly. I did that 3 years ago when I restored the CIS system but many original hoses still remain. They're rugged looking units! And yes, you can't really complain much about 27 year old system having a bad day.

RarlyL8 05-01-2005 04:16 PM

The problem has been eleminated. Litterally.

It was not the WUR. The two P-mechanics that diagnosed the WUR was the culprit are gonna have a crow sandwich. What was the problem? Well a couple of you hit the nail right on the head. You saved me some valuable time and money thrown at parts replacement.

I stripped off the CIS this morning to check all the vacuum hoses. It didn't take me long to find the culprit. The only peice of non-essential CIS equipment left on the system bit me. The throttle cable had been rubbing up against one of the vacuum hoses on the Decel Valve. It finally rubbed through.

Here is a picture of the culprit:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1114992031.jpg

I removed this defective valve and plugged the holes.

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1114992104.jpg


The car started immediately. I put the adjustment screw on the WUR back to where it was originally and set the Fuel Head mixture by ear. After the car warmed up I checked the CO%, it was at 1.7%. I left it alone for now.

I've got to say a few words about the importance of the testing equipment used.
The CIS Pressure Tester told me that the WUR was functioning but a bit weak. That is why I started this thread. Mechanics were telling me the WUR was bad while the Pressure Tester told me otherwise.
The A/F Ratio Meter spotted this problem months ago. It is a narrow band unit. I have been told many times that a narrow band meter is not accurate. Well it was accurate enough to tell me I was lean without any other symptoms.
The Gunson Gas Tester always verifies the mixture. This is a very accurate machine if you allow it to warm up past the point of baseline drift. That is about 30 minutes.

We can now add this mistery solved to out growing archive of CIS tidbits. As these systems age they get more quirky and difficult to diagnose. Thank you all very much for taking the time to help me with this.

The car is now happily boosting once again!!


http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1114992883.jpg

Stephen B 05-02-2005 07:30 AM

Can one of you guys tell me what purpose the deceleration valve serves?

Never mind!! Answered my own question by doing a search.

cowtown 05-02-2005 07:41 AM

Rarly, like you, I'm not running any of those non-essential parts on my 930 engine. I also don't have the decel valve - just the FD and WUR with a hand-throttle for cold starts. It runs fine. One more thing you can leave in the closet.

Porsche_monkey 05-02-2005 07:59 AM

For anyone with CIS trouble a vacuum leak test with an unlit propane torch would have found that problem quickly. It takes about two minutes to check all the lines.

Paulporsche 05-02-2005 08:22 AM

PBH,
Absolutely. One of the first things RarlyL8 mentioned was that all his vacuum lines "appear(ed)" sound. Literally. By eye.

RarlyL8,
Glad to see you are back in business. BTW, car looks nice...not the car of a crotchety old bastard!

SpeedracerIndy 05-02-2005 08:25 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Stephen B
Can one of you guys tell me what purpose the deceleration valve serves?

Never mind!! Answered my own question by doing a search.

The decel valve allows extra air to pass the throttle plate when you let off the throttle. It is essentially an emmission component and prevents backfire from a rich condition after the throttle is abruptly closed. If it's not there, the engine revs will simply fall faster after you let off the gas. It can be the culprit of a high idle after warm up when it wears out.

oops, just noticed you found the answer, nevermind...

Stephen B 05-02-2005 08:38 AM

Thanks for the reply Speed. I have an intermittent high idle after warm start... the d valve checked out last time the I/C was removed, but I didn't check the hoses closely - just valve function / diaphragm integrity. From my searches it sounds like the valve can be removed without any problems.

Paulporsche 05-02-2005 08:41 AM

Some actually prefer the valve removed. Besides one less component or hose to fail, the absence of the valve allows to revs to fall quicker when off the gas.

hobieboy 05-02-2005 08:48 AM

I have been following this very closely with great interest as I also have some CIS issues - the car starts well cold & hot, but when cold, mixture simply richens but the RPM does not rise (so it idles @ ~600rpm). When warm, idles goes up to 1100.

Sounds like my decel valve might be one of the culprit for high warm idle? And I plan to take a look at my AAV as well.

RarlyL8 05-02-2005 09:09 AM

I actually left the valve on intentionally to KEEP THE REVS UP between shifts. On a turbo this is a GOOD thing. What I did not realize at the time was this valve was not working. It never did work. Only by removing it did I find this out. All that time I thought the light weight fly wheel was causing the tach to drop like a rock between shifts. I was manually matching revs like I did in my old '73T.

How does this propane deal work for checking vacuum leaks? Never heard of that before.

Anybody need a rebuilt WUR for a 930? Don't think I'll have use for that now.

Paulporsche 05-02-2005 09:20 AM

Hobieboy,
Check your AAR. That's what keeps your revs up during warmup idling. The AAV only comes into play during startup. Also check your Cold Control Pressure. Quite often the mix is too lean @ the warmup phase but OK when warm. This is controlled by the WUR. And don't forget those vacuum leaks.

Porsche_monkey 05-02-2005 09:24 AM

Propane will be sucked in through a vacuum leak and you will here the idle speed raise from the added fuel. Quick-start (ether) also works. I just use actylene from my cutting torch.

Just hold it in front of your cold air intake to see (hear) the effect.

SpeedracerIndy 05-02-2005 10:10 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Stephen B
Thanks for the reply Speed. I have an intermittent high idle after warm start... the d valve checked out last time the I/C was removed, but I didn't check the hoses closely - just valve function / diaphragm integrity. From my searches it sounds like the valve can be removed without any problems.
The decel valve is also adjustable. That makes it easier to troubleshoot (as long as your lines aren't leaking). I had a high idle when warm problem that I cured by adjusting the decel valve. There is a nut with a stud through it on the top of the valve that you can turn to adjust how long it holds the revs up after releasing the throttle. i can't remember off the top of my head which way to turn it though. There are also two types of decel valves. One (like mine) is a smaller bell shaped object that sits up high behind the throttle body, the other type looks like the aav, and sits on the passengers side of the engine.

Stephen B 05-02-2005 11:20 AM

My decel valve is mounted to the turbo bypass valve assembly. Gold colored can above the coil in the attached picture.
http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1115061085.jpg

RarlyL8 05-02-2005 04:58 PM

OK, got the propane deal. You use propane the way I use ether. The small red tube attached to the spray nozzle really helps direct the spray to exactly where you want it.
This time I didn't need to use a chemical sniffer, the damage to the hose was obvious. These hoses have 3 layers. It takes quite a bit for one to leak. The real stresser for them is 2 decades sitting on top a hot engine.
Steve, the valve you show pictured is the one I removed. Is your engine a Euro? Some of the induction components are a different configuration that stock US. What is that clear fiter for?
Hobieboy, I agree with Paul. A non functioning (or in my case absent) AAV will cause exactly the symptoms you describe. There are many components in the stock CIS system that kick up the idle when cold. It is unusual that none of them are working.
When you say high warm idle is your 1100rpm idle speed at the end of adjusment with the idle screw? If so then yes the decel could be the culprit. That is exactly where my warm idle was with all the adjustment used up at the idle screw. With the decel valve removed and capped off the warm idle has dropped to ~950rpm. Remeber tough that there is a 3-way going on between idle set screw, ignition timing, and fuel head mixture. All affect idle speed.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 09:35 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.