Mr. Regular does *not* like the 944

[p-talk]

I really enjoy the YouTube show Regular Car Reviews, but they were not kind in their review of the 944s. Not that I am surprised, it's not their kind of car. But he was pretty harsh. I can't help but wonder if there are issues with this particular car, as any 944s really takes off in the higher RPM range.

Enjoy!

[Brozoar]

I had a friend who didn't care for the 944 because he found the engine rather charmless. If he was going to have a four-cylinder sports car, he said, he'd want a "small, rev-happy" unit that made all its power in the upper reaches of the RPM range (a-la Honda S2000).

I can understand that, and it seems from his comments that Mr. Regular might feel the same. But then, plenty of commenters say he was cruel in his review of the Honda, too.

I want to chalk this up to a case of "it has a Porsche badge; it should be a revelation and instead, it's merely 'good.'"

[sausagehacker]

Never understood the huge following behind that channel. The lack of real content would be justified if the videos were at least funny, but they aren't.

[Jfrahm]

Oh man often they are very very funny. At least to me.

Dodge Aspen review, for example:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wGnMVijx5GE

[Alexb944]

their review on the subaru brat was hallarious, especially if your drunk... which i may have been.

[Brozoar]

It took me a long, long time to warm up to his content. My friends tell me I talk exactly like him, and have the same sense of humor, which is patently absurd; when I tell a joke, it actually makes sense.

BUT... yeah, I've warmed on Regular Car Reviews, partly because he's gotten much better. That said, he seems to regurgitate Wikipedia a lot, and if he had a lackluster experience in a 944S, he probably doesn't know how to drive it proper.

[pfarah]

I wasn't impressed with his review by any means. 10 yr run with over 100k made; Porsche did something right. Anyone who shares his view is cordially invited to PM me and I'll be happy to take the car off your hands

[ckelly78z]

My 944 engine was rather charmless until I mounted the WILKS chip, and the weltermeister throttle cam.......completely different car, and now lively, and free revving.

[grendiers]

Yeah, what 30+ year old platform is still out there in the range of 944 numbers? Datsun Z cars? Not so much. VW Siroccos? Nope. Mazda RX7's? Nope again.

[Rasta Monsta]

Originally Posted by Brozoar

I want to chalk this up to a case of "it has a Porsche badge; it should be a revelation and instead, it's merely 'good.'"

Agree. This phenomenon plagues the 924. . .can you imagine how collectible they would be now if they had been manufactured by VW as originally planned?

[Brozoar]

Another theory is that the 944S Mr. Regular tested was ruined by the wheels in more ways than one. I just don't see how he could hate on any up-to-snuff 944 so much.

Of course, we are all the least-unbiased people in the world on this...

[Litesonic]

I would argue (imho sadly) that most of the driveable 944s fall into the category shown in the review... and that is because rather than maintain a car, people throw on rimz, a sub woofer, LEDs and on and on. They try to make it more modern... detaching it from its correct place and time.

Here's the thing. If someone is experiencing happiness in a 944... that, in itself, is great and usually fleeting.

That car's owner loves it. I can respect that.

[djnolan]

Poppycock: The 944 feels like a brick **** house compared to any 80's car out there and is galvanized to boot. Camaros were front heavy sleds with crude handling, corvettes were overweight and handled crudely, too, Z's were too light in the rear and flimsy to boot and I wasn't impressed with Miatas either, seemed to heavy for the power plant. Maybe a Mits 3000 or a Stealth was nimble, but still not properly balanced.

[Brozoar]

Well, this is very illuminating.

[cockerpunk]

he's right you know. NA 944s are pretty damn slow and there isnt much you can do about it.

[petrolhead611]

They weren't slow in 1982 when they came out, and the 944S certainly wasn't in '86.Compare to other sporting cars available then, not cars of today. They were geared for European motorways, there was no speed limit on Autobahns back then and you could drive them flat out thereon. Driving down to the Nurburgring on the E61 in 1989 or so, I held my 924S at an indicated 130mph all the way. Only car to pass me was a BMW 3.0CSL. And then when it came to track driving, it was pretty peerless for a volume produced 2+2 car of its engine size back then.
30 years later , surprise surprise, car performance has improved

[dgcantrell]

All I have to say is send me all of your "unloved" 914's, 924's, 944's, and 968's and I'll give them all a good home. Feel free to toss in any "unloved" 911,912, or 356's my way too. I'll take them all free of charge.. ;-)

[OPRN]

I agree, compared with the new stuff, ya but in the early 80's they were pretty impressive cars.

My automotive's teacher in high school told us about his best buddy getting a Ford Model T for his first car back when they were young. His buddy planned a trip to the US and invited him to come along. He said he was very disappointed with the trip when he got back home because buddy drove so fast they didn't get a chance to see any scenery. He drove 30 MPH all the way there and back!!

That's how it goes, our expectations change. The 944 is just as awesome as it ever was seen through 1983 eyes! The amazing thing about them to me is they are still with us and they may not win now but they give many of the latest and greatest a serious run for their money!

[Fast Freddy 944]

Its funny how folks dislike any 80's back supercar's, or sports cars, I get stares when I drive my 951, hell I get stares when I drive the family 66 mgb. The way I see it, I love the wedge look of the car, and having a turbo in the 951, well that's just the bee's knee's!
compared to the pea-pod, insect looking vehicles today, ill take my 951 any day!

[v2rocket_aka944]

Originally Posted by Rasta Monsta

Agree. This phenomenon plagues the 924. . .can you imagine how collectible they would be now if they had been manufactured by VW as originally planned?

plaid...plaid everywhere