1. 2005 Mini Cooper S convertible, 25k miles, $17k
2. 2005 Mini Cooper non-S convertible, 65k miles, $13.5k
Of course go with the cheaper car that's non import. The S vs. non S is moot, they are both turds in terms of performance - at least if you consider the fact that you are posting amongst Porsche aficionados.

- the S supposedly runs a 7.7s 0-60. That's really slow for something bearing an "S" badge IMHO - a stock 911 SC from 1978 will outrun that.
Full Test: 2005 Mini Cooper and Cooper S Convertibles
George