Did you consider the S2000 before buying your Boxster?

cantdrv55 · 01-30-2007, 10:33 AM

Just wondering what sold you on the Boxster if you considered the S2000. The Honda is so much cheaper, well-built, a serious track car and easy to maintain (that's what I hear). It know it's just a Honda but that's not necessarily a bad thing. Did you buy the Boxster soley because it's a Porsche or was it something/combination of things?

I've driven a 2001 S2000 and a 2.5 Boxster only. The driving experience (short test drive) was equal. I don't know how a 2.2 liter S2000 and a Boxster S would compare. I do know they are at least about 10 grand apart used in similar condition/vintage.

superglide · 01-30-2007, 01:35 PM

was this a reply to another thread? a general question to Boxster owners, in general? or are you just staring into the sky and wondering....? why is there air? so that we may play volleyball, of course. IMHO; the S2000 is a great affordable sport-car in the same way that their 2-stroke motorbikes compare to a european 4-stroke... in price, performance, handling and quality, and class. But Bruce Anderson said it best "buy the newest and best that you can afford..."

cantdrv55 · 01-30-2007, 01:42 PM

I should've searched to find out if a similar thread has been started. This is a general question aimed at Boxster owners. I'm at a crossroads with my 911s. I'll have to sell my SC now to buy a 2004 S2000 or save up a little longer and sell my Carrera to buy a 2005 Boxster S. I just wanted to know why you bought your 986 or 987 instead of a S2000.

superglide · 01-30-2007, 01:58 PM

ah, now we have a basis... I am in LOVE with my 911sc. with that said; I bought the 986S because it was one of those deals I couldn't pass up. and as Mom said "I love them both, just differently."

But they are definately two different cars. I miss the uncomplicated raw-ness of the 911 when I'm enjoying the plush, sophisticated 986, and vice versa. that's why I still own them both, and it's a course I'd recommend, if it's at all feasible... But a Honda? there is nothing about it's styling, build quality, or performance characteristics that appeal to me. to paraphrase: "I'd rather have a sister in a whorehouse than a brother in a Honda..."

racer · 01-30-2007, 03:24 PM

I thought about a used S2000. Then I woke up and remembered I wanted another Porsche... not just another "car". While I never test drove one, I do admire their performance potential. What likely impacted my decision was my experience with my 2.0l WRX. NO low end TORQUE. Same holds true for the S2000. I don't want to have to rev to 6K rpm to finally "get going".

I too, had a 911SC. In fact, I sold it to get my Boxster (2000, non-s). I don't miss my SC yet I love the Boxster. Great balance, great sounds, good power and torque.

Why do you "need" a 2005 S vs previous year "S"s?

Best way to decide is to test drive all 3 (986S, 987S and S2000) in conditions you will use the car... in a commute for an hr? Pleasure driving? track driving? Be fair. Pick the one that is right for you

cantdrv55 · 01-30-2007, 03:56 PM

I like the 2005 because of the restyle and more hp. I'd like to test drive a 987S but I feel like a user if I ask to test drive knowing that I cannot buy one for a couple of years.

7th gear · 01-31-2007, 03:13 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by superglide
to paraphrase: "I'd rather have a sister in a whorehouse than a brother in a Honda..."

what do you mean?

superglide · 01-31-2007, 04:30 AM

I mean that I personally don't care for the S2000, whether or not it is in comparison to a Porsche.....

kirk4 · 01-31-2007, 06:33 AM

I think if you look at any Porsche purchase pure economics is not the only reason to buy one. I wanted a Porsche and although I'm sure that other cars out perform my 02 S it's what I wanted. Every car is a combination of metal but there are some that just stir your soul.

superglide · 01-31-2007, 07:08 AM

That's it exactly, Kirk, the Objective, and the Subjective. And if I were basing my purchase solely on price and performance, I'd go buy a Corvette, not an S2000, in any case.

7th gear · 01-31-2007, 08:26 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by superglide
I mean that I personally don't care for the S2000, whether or not it is in comparison to a Porsche.....

oh well, at least you understand.

my confusion just doubled.

superglide · 01-31-2007, 08:38 AM

it's just an old expression.

FrayAdjacent911 · 01-31-2007, 09:20 AM

The Honda was not a consideration... since I wanted a Porsche.

I'm sure an S2000 might come pretty close to my base Boxster, but I'd still rather have the Boxster... because... well, it's a PORSCHE.

Not to dog the Honda, they are great cars, and they'll probably last forever and have few problems. They're also cheaper to fix, and aftermarket goodies are usually more plentiful and also cost less.

7th gear · 02-02-2007, 03:29 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by superglide
to paraphrase: "I'd rather have a sister in a whorehouse than a brother in a Honda..."

Quote:

I mean that I personally don't care for the S2000, whether or not it is in comparison to a Porsche.....

Quote:

it's just an old expression

hmmm....somehow your equation just doesn't seem to add up.

by what you write ... the sister, whorehouse & porsche seem to go together and they're good. the brother & honda joined and are bad or lower. please elaborate how these things adhere to each other.

if you mean 'that you don't care for the s2000, whether or not it is in comparison to a porsche', it might be appropriate to just state that. why bring up an 'old expression' of this nature to describe your love for the porsche?? i know what you're really trying to say but i'm giving you the benefit of the doubt because i'm sure you mean well in some way.

when you really break all this down to it's most primitive form, every last car on the road ... big/small, fast/slow, foreign/domestic will get you from one place to the next. the sparkle of the car/bike & our ego are the things that get in the way.

superglide · 02-02-2007, 09:29 AM

Just let it go..... This is a forum about fine automobiles; not philosophy.
Happy Motoring.

Grant Lenahan · 02-04-2007, 05:10 AM

I did drive the S2000. Nice car. As you say, a "smart buy". Though I was almost pre-sold on e boxster since it was the first car in a LONG while that gave me the tactile feedback and "one-ness" that I wanted. I had the chance to drive a boxster extensively before I bought.

That said, I think the 986 has several advantages over the S2000:

- torque. Big time difference.
- ride quality - ditto
- interior space
- storage space - ditto
- top convenience and quality (to my feel)

The 986 is very much an everyday car for me. The Honda might not cut it in the same role - although it is an excellent and over looked choice. Might be a great track/sunday afternoon car. Overall I could not be happier with the 986, by the way.

Grant

Marc Gelefsky · 02-04-2007, 12:16 PM

Nope, I am a Porsche guy, did not even consider the S2000.