To Fuch or not to Fuch?

Mr Beau · 02-16-2016, 10:27 PM

I'm thinking of selling my black '73E. It didn't have Fuch's from the factory and was wonder if it would sell for more with cookies or Fuch's? I have a set of (polished) later style 15x6" Fuch's on it now. I had planned on refinishing them to period correct (as it's my visual preference) but was wondering if I should change them out for cookies instead. And how important would '73 dated cookies be??

gearby · 02-16-2016, 11:17 PM

It will sell better with the fuchs on it but I would offer up the cookies with the sale of the car. Cookies don't have much value so just give them away with the sale of the car.

Racerbvd · Racerbvd's Garage

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr Beau

I'm thinking of selling my black '73E. It didn't have Fuch's from the factory and was wonder if it would sell for more with cookies or Fuch's? I have a set of (polished) later style 15x6" Fuch's on it now. I had planned on refinishing them to period correct (as it's my visual preference) but was wondering if I should change them out for cookies instead. And how important would '73 dated cookies be??

10 years ago, it would be Fuchs, all day long, but with the increased values of air cooled 911s, and people going by the COAs, find a correct set of wheels and offer the Fuchs (I would keep em, but everyone knows how I am about Fuchs) separate.

Not many long hood 911s running around with Cookies.. And have you noticed the price of matching date coded Steel rims lately?
http://forums.pelicanparts.com/porsche-marketplace-discussion/901168-ats-cookie-cutter-6x15-1973-a.html

KNS · 02-17-2016, 06:25 AM

I think Cookies are a bit more sought after today than a few years ago. I've always liked them.

brisboats · brisboats's Garage

Quote:

Originally Posted by KNS

I think Cookies are a bit more sought after today than a few years ago. I've always liked them.

+1
Cookies are often preferred now at least with the 944 crowd over fuchs. As far as 911's to me I would want a set of fuchs even if it came with cookies, steelys or even phone dials. Like Gearby said offer up the cookies with the sale.
B

tom6284 · tom6284's Garage

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/porsche-911-used-parts-sale-wanted/902199-cookie-cutter-rims-tires-1976-set-silver.html

Mr Beau · 02-17-2016, 01:16 PM

I sold the cookies a long time ago when I 'upgraded' to 16" Boxster wheels...

On a related note, what should the spare be?

Ronnie's.930 · 02-17-2016, 01:23 PM

Matt B., if I was selling a car and someone wanted to quibble over the asking price due to the presence of Fuchs instead of cookies, I would tell them to "get to steppin'" and sell the car to someone who didn't have Sesame seeds for nads! In other words, I am sure you can price the car where you want, regardless of the wheels, and someone will be glad to buy it as is.

brisboats · brisboats's Garage

That makes sense if you don't have a set of cookies no sweat. Price it with the Fuchs you have. If you want some cookies let me know. My Nephew is dismantling 944's now and has a few sets. Of course not going to be date coded 73 but ... ? Still cheap.
B

brisboats · brisboats's Garage

Of course cookies on a 73 can look pretty cool!
B

Matt Monson · 02-17-2016, 04:29 PM

I've got a set of 75 cookies. They are black. I'd sell them.

But if it were me is sell it with the Fuchs and not think twice about it. Most will consider it an upgrade even if it's not original to the car.

brisboats · brisboats's Garage

Forget the black . Guy on here has some date coded 73's if you want to stay original.
B

brisboats · brisboats's Garage

Let's face it a 73 911 with black cookies would be... Well just wrong. The ones we offered are silver ats wheels. All of the ones we have are silver , no ugh black. Funny how M&M is always accusing me of stepping on his posts and as soon as I offer up something for sale he swoops in to sell his items. Hmmm.

B

Scottc714 · 02-17-2016, 05:16 PM

just wondering if the black cookies offered up would be "rubbish" if offered by anyone other than Matt?

brisboats · brisboats's Garage

Yeah Scott sure would
73's never came with black Fuchs. Course M and. M didn't know that .

brisboats · brisboats's Garage

Matt Monson · 05:52 PM

Giant Shakey head. Bris is home alone drinking again instead of working on his lesson plans.

And never mind that 944 cookies like he offered were usually black.

Ronnie's.930 · 05:59 PM

Cookies are just goofy, regardless of the car they are on (steelies are worse, though, fit only for a box truck), Matt M. sells garbage and knows nothing about auto mechanics or 911 history, and Boats's fecal matter smells like roses and he's a real sensitive, yet macho guy (so he says)!!!

brisboats · brisboats's Garage

Matt that's a pic from a 1973 Porsche brochure.
Please stop with the defamatory comments.
B

Matt Monson · 02-17-2016, 06:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by brisboats

Matt that's a pic from a 1973 Porsche brochure.
Please stop with the defamatory comments or you are about to get the lesson of a lifetime . Try me.
B

You start something and get all whiny and make threats when I talk back?
BTW, Wayne bans people for making threats. Of any passing reader reports this post your gone for a month or two.

Plus what too gonna do, sue me? Show up and shoot me? You really need to take a step back and look in the mirror. I think your mother would be disgusted with the kind of person you are choosing to be. You go around an internet forum stalking a guy who hurt your feelings. I'd leave you alone if you didn't keep seeking me out and attacking me over and over.