Which song is better

Shaun @ Tru6 · 11-03-2023, 12:52 PM

Tobra · Tobra's Garage

Second one, not even close

pwd72s · 11-03-2023, 01:06 PM

Never liked Cobain's voice, so the choice is obvious to me. You do realize that You really got me is a cover?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fTTsY-oz6Go&ab_channel=TheKinks

herr_oberst · 11-03-2023, 01:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pwd72s

Never liked Cobain's voice

herr_oberst · 01:25 PM

I choose song #3

(Eruption isn't close to the best VH song, and GnR never "took" for me.)

70SATMan · 11-03-2023, 01:22 PM

I’d have liked GnR if they had a different lead. A male frontman would have worked. Can’t stand that whiny beyotches voice.

While I love Eddie, got to choose GnR here because it’s NOT a cover. Plus, it should be canon that Kink’s songs shall not be sung by non Kinks UNLESS they are punks.

mgatepi · 11-03-2023, 01:24 PM

GnR all the way

pwd72s · 11-03-2023, 01:26 PM

Whoops...just showed how little I know about Guns & Roses...never liked 'em. Van Halen another story...

Tobra · Tobra's Garage

The part after the intro by Eddie is all superfluous

flatbutt · 11-03-2023, 01:35 PM

I have always liked McKagans bass line in Sweet Child.

Baz · Baz's Garage

Shaun @ Tru6 · 11-03-2023, 01:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by flatbutt

I have always liked McKagans bass line in Sweet Child.

You get it. While Eruption is all instrumental, Sweet Child has, I think, parts that are just as good and even better. Or maybe just different better if that makes any sense.

You have to listen to the music, not the song.

Ayles · 11-03-2023, 02:56 PM

So timely! Adding these to my jukebox this afternoon:

WPOZZZ · 11-03-2023, 03:46 PM

GnR.

astrochex · 11-03-2023, 04:17 PM

I like SCOM as a complete song. I love Eruption (its quintessential VH in my book), but YRGM for me gets weird and less likeable.

JavaBrewer · JavaBrewer's Garage

I have not watched the OP links, assuming they are the original band videos. How did Foo Fighters and Cobain enter the thread?

Loved GnR but only for a few songs. VH has a huge body of work across multiple frontmen and they are just a handful of bands I can play an album (no longer in existence) without having to skip a song.

Since Foo Fighers were mentioned they also have some iconic tunes. Still my favorite rock song is by Smashing Pumpkins

WSH · 11-03-2023, 04:55 PM

La Villa Strangiato

Bob Kontak · Bob Kontak's Garage

Quote:

Originally Posted by JavaBrewer

How did Foo Fighters and Cobain enter the thread?

PWD mentioned he did not like Cobain's voice but it was Axl Rose he was thinking of.

I choose GnR.

Please, don't muddy the thread with an off topic song again.

masraum · 11-03-2023, 05:14 PM

I liked GnR and had a couple of their CDs, but I think that Van Halen especially with DL Roth was better. I'll have to listen to the two songs.

Eruption is killer, but is just the intro for "You Really Got Me". I feel like I'd have to compare that to "Sweet Child of Mine".

I haven't listened to GnR in a long time. I have listened to Van Halen.

flatbutt · 11-03-2023, 06:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaun @ Tru6

You get it. While Eruption is all instrumental, Sweet Child has, I think, parts that are just as good and even better. Or maybe just different better if that makes any sense.

You have to listen to the music, not the song.

There's quite a lot of structure in SCOM and it's simplicity is belied by the manner in which it is woven together.

eg...Slashes riff is 8 notes played in essentially a stepwise fashion. McKagans line is more complex and is set more or less as counterpoint to Slash's riff.

The drums set a rhythm that is (to my ear) anticipatory in that the second strike comes in just a wee bit sooner than expected which gives the song an edge.

If I had the score I could really make your eyes glaze over.