Supercar attrition, WSJ article

[Chuck Moreland]

It does seem that a lot of Carrara GTs and Enzos are being smashed up.

Maybe these wrecks are just getting more exposure because everyone has digital cameras. Combine with the satisfaction many get when they see a wealthy person stumble. So the internet spreads these pics like wildfire.

Following article from the wall street journal:

Honey, I Wrecked the Porsche
Fast, powerful and out of control. Jennifer Saranow on why some drivers are finding their new cars too hot to handle.
By JENNIFER SARANOW
June 15, 2007; Page W1

Call it a metaphor for a prosperous, risk-embracing age or just call it bad driving.
[Crash slideshow]

Auto makers are turning out a new breed of supremely fast sports cars that sell for upwards of $250,000 and share many characteristics of purebred racecars. But as more of them hit the road, often in the hands of inexperienced drivers, a growing number are ending up wrapped around trees, smashed into guardrails or otherwise totaled in accidents.

In the past 18 months, drivers across the world have cracked up at least six rare $1 million Ferrari Enzos -- only 400 of which were built. In March, a California man rammed his $300,000 Lamborghini Murcielago into five parked cars; while in England, a 39-year-old driver caused an international stir among car enthusiasts by crashing a Bugatti Veyron -- an extremely rare $1.5 million turbocharged missile with a top speed of 253 miles per hour.

It's not just drunken celebrities doing the damage. On the way to an M.B.A. class near San Diego one recent morning, Nasar Aboubakare, a 40-year-old private-equity firm president, lost control of his new 550-horsepower Ford GT and wrenched it over a lane divider. "The car is like a wild animal," he says.

To compound matters, it's tough to be inconspicuous when you damage a $150,000 automobile. After Mr. Aboubakare's accident, several passing motorists snapped pictures while one leaned out the window of his pickup truck and shouted: "What an idiot!"

Police in wealthy enclaves across the country say these accidents are not unusual. A spokesman for the Beverly Hills Police Department says his officers "regularly" handle accidents involving exotic vehicles, while Sgt. Jeffrey Kelly from Boca Raton, Fla., says his department has logged two Ferrari crashes in the past two years. "We've had our fair share," he says.
WSJ's Jennifer Saranow reports on the increasing number of accidents and wealthy sports-car owners who don't just take weekend drives.

According to the California Highway Patrol, the total number of accidents involving Aston Martins, Bentleys, Ferraris, Lamborghinis, Lotuses and Maseratis rose to 141 last year, an 81% increase from 2002, while overall crashes declined statewide during that period. Porsche, BMW and Mercedes-Benz, which sell a wider range of models, saw a 22% increase during that time frame.

These accidents are happening so regularly that a Web site called WreckedExotics.com -- which contains photos of dream cars reduced to smoking heaps -- added as many as 700 new examples to its gallery last year and says it attracts about 650,000 visitors a month. Founder Gregg Fidan explains the attraction this way: "It's like seeing a supermodel fall off the runway."

More Cars, More Crashes
[Show] AUTO SHOP

See some of the top-of-the-line supercars and prototypes that auto makers have unveiled recently.

One reason for the increase is that there are simply more of these so-called "supercars" on the road. CNW Marketing Research, a firm that analyzes the auto market, says Americans bought about 8,400 "ultra-luxury" sports cars last year -- more than three times the number from 2003. While the number of supercars registered in California is up sharply, the rate at which they are getting into accidents is still small -- just over 1% -- and hasn't changed appreciably since the state began breaking data down by make in 2002. (The statewide accident rate for all vehicles was 3%.)

Stefan Winkelmann, president and chief executive officer of Lamborghini, a unit of Volkswagen's Audi Group, says he's aware of "four or five" incidents involving one of the company's new 640-horsepower Murcielagos -- a small fraction of the nearly 500 models the company sold last year. Toscan Bennett, a spokesman for Ferrari, a unit of Fiat Group, says the company does not track the number of accidents involving its cars, but adds that several high-profile incidents may have contributed to a false impression that these crashes are common.

Auto makers say the rising horsepower is being offset by safety advancements ranging from all-wheel drive to ceramic brakes, rear-view cameras, extra airbags and monocoque safety cages that direct impact forces away from passengers. "The cars give themselves up for the safety of the driver," says Porsche spokesman Tony Fouladpour. Many supercars come with traction and stability control systems that automatically vary the power delivered to the wheels to help prevent drivers from sliding and skidding.

Insurance companies say that while the majority of supercar accidents do not result in serious injuries, there has been an uptick in collision claims on these cars. In some cases, rates are rising. Based on the rising cost of claims, State Farm says the same driver would have paid 9% more last year to buy physical damage insurance for a new Lamborghini Murcielago than in 2003.

Expensive sports cars have always been intimidatingly fast, but experts say the latest models are not just more powerful, they're also lighter: Ferrari's new 599 GTB Fiorano produces about .164 horsepower per pound -- a 21% improvement over the model it replaced. The trouble begins when overconfident drivers start trying to push the cars to speeds that even experienced drivers may not be capable of handling. "Generally speaking, the cars are well over the heads of the drivers," says Glenn Roberts, the owner of an auto-body shop in Fountain Hills, Ariz., that repairs damaged exotic cars.

The people buying these cars are also changing. Unlike previous supercar collectors who often babied their machines, they tend to drive about 4,000 to 6,000 miles per year -- more than double the average from a decade ago. And they're not getting any more mature: the median age for ultra-luxury sports-car buyers dropped to 47 last year from an average of 56 just 10 years ago, according to CNW. And you don't have to be an actuary to know that younger people are more likely to drive aggressively. A spokeswoman for Leland-West Insurance Brokers says most of the supercar claims the company handles each year involve men aged 25 to 40 driving newer high-performance cars too fast and losing control.

'Controllable' Speed

Adnan K. Mehmood, a 32-year-old fabric importer and stock trader from Miami, counts himself among those who don't believe a high-performance car should be pampered. He says he has driven his 2006 Lamborghini Murcielago Roadster faster than 191 mph a number of times on freeways. Mr. Mehmood says it's the engineering that gives him the confidence to go that fast. "When you are in the car, it's so stable," he says. "It's such a controllable speed. In a normal car when you are going 80 or 90, it feels like you are going really, really fast. In the Lambo, you are going 120 or 140 and honestly, it feels like it's stopped on the freeway. It feels like it's not moving."

He is awaiting delivery of Lamborghini's new Murcielago LP640 Roadster, which has an extra 60 horsepower and a new suspension design that will help make it one of the fastest cars the company has ever built -- traveling up to 211 mph and from 0 to 60 in 3.7 seconds. "I want to go to 200 mph," Mr. Mehmood says.

Veteran sports-car connoisseur Michael Fux says he has a pretty good idea why all these crashes are happening. The 64-year-old mattress entrepreneur from Miami, whose collection includes a Bugatti Veyron, a Ferrari 599, an Enzo and five Lamborghinis, says younger drivers are constantly challenging him to race. "These kids, they don't use their heads," he says. "They think they're back in the old Wild West."

[Chuck Moreland]

Driving experts say most accidents in these cars happen when drivers take turns too fast for the road conditions or start turning prematurely and then snap off the accelerator to compensate. If the car's back end starts to fishtail, many inexperienced drivers will fail to steer in the direction of the sliding tail or will overcorrect by turning too severely in that direction. Both mistakes can cause a spin. "It's a symphony of inputs and adjustments to keep the car under control," says David Champion, senior director of Consumer Reports Auto Test Division.
[Crash]
Anthony Almada's $440,000 Porsche Carrera GT

For Anthony Almada, a 46-year-old nutritional biochemist and entrepreneur from Dana Point, Calif., the catalyst was a deceivingly slick road. While driving his $440,000 Porsche Carrera GT on a bend near his home at 80 miles per hour on a slightly wet road early last year, he says the car snapped into a spin. He followed the procedure he'd been taught in driving class and "put both feet in" -- pressing down on the brake and the clutch at the same time -- and hoped for the best. The car broadsided a brick wall and spun at least six times and caught fire. "It wasn't something I could have corrected," says Mr. Almada, who climbed out unhurt. "I was going too fast for the road conditions. It's that simple."

Another common mistake: failing to warm up the tires. Standing inside his garage last month at Classic Coach Repair in Elizabeth, N.J., owner Onofrio Triarsi points out two damaged Ferraris -- a red 360 that needs a new quarter panel and bumper and a blue 550 Maranello with similar damage. Both cars had been taken out on racetracks on cold mornings by drivers who had not given the tires enough time to heat up (and thus adhere better to the asphalt). When customers drive off now, Mr. Triarsi leaves them with the same advice: "Don't forget the tires."

In some cases, drivers say they got into trouble after shutting off the car's traction control system to get a more "authentic" sports-car experience. During a test for Car and Driver last spring in Italy, technical editor Aaron Robinson, 37, flicked off the electronic stability control in a 611-horsepower Ferrari 599 GTB Fiorano so he could get the vehicle's rear end to flare out around a curve for a photo. But after giving the car "too much throttle and not enough core steering," he says he wound up sideswiping a wall. "Any car with 600 horsepower is intimidating," Mr. Robinson says.

Many of these accidents are, of course, just examples of pure recklessness. The Bugatti Veyron owner who crashed in Surrey, England, this year was said to be traveling at least 100 mph on a country lane before colliding with a station wagon. He was cited by police for driving "without due care and attention." The 26-year-old who crashed his 2005 Lamborghini into five parked cars in Santa Monica, Calif., in March was reportedly racing at 75 mph around a 35 mph curve. He was charged with driving under the influence.

You don't have to buy one of these cars to trash one, either: New York's Gotham Dream Cars, one of a growing number of companies that allow people to rent supercars for the day, says about one in 50 of its rentals comes back damaged.

High Speed, Low Clearance

Speed isn't always the culprit. Because of their odd dimensions and miniscule ground clearance, supercars have always been vulnerable to damage from curbs, speed bumps or even objects in the road. While driving his yellow Ferrari Enzo for only the third time, Ali Haas, a 51-year-old plastic surgeon from Florida, ran over a spool of wire on the road. In most cars this would have been a nonevent -- but in this case the low-slung Ferrari was knocked airborne, breaking its grip on the road and sending it skidding into a guardrail. "If I ran over that spool of wire in my Ford Expedition, probably nothing would have happened," Dr. Haas says.

Regardless of the cause, anyone who wrecks one of these cars has a more immediate problem than finding a mechanic: the possibility of public humiliation. After smashing his silver Ferrari 360 into a light pole in November in Palm Beach, Fla., David Riggs says none of the 50 or so onlookers who stopped to gawk asked him if he was OK. Instead, the 42-year-old says he heard comments like "wow, you are really having a bad day," "that is really a bummer," and "your toy is broke." "Nobody is really concerned if you are hurt," Mr. Riggs says.

Car companies say they do what they can to make sure their most powerful vehicles get into the hands of experienced drivers. Buyers of Ferrari limited-production cars like the Enzo "were chosen by the factory based on their history and loyalty to Ferrari," says the spokesman, Mr. Bennett.

Driving Academies

Manufacturers are also rolling out driver-education programs. Later this year, Bugatti plans to start offering buyers a "security driving course" at a test track near its factory in France. Ferrari has offered driver training in Italy since the early 1990s and just opened the first authorized school outside Italy last year in Mt. Tremblant, Canada. Lamborghini started offering winter and summer-driving academies last year, formalizing classes long offered by dealers.

Bentley offered its first driving class in the U.S. last year and Lotus is launching a driving school in the U.S. this month called the Lotus Performance Driving Experience outside Las Vegas that will include instruction in "the dynamics of skid control."
[Crash]

One recent driving-school graduate: Mr. Aboubakare, the private-equity company president who spun out his Ford GT. He hopes to be better equipped to drive the new Lamborghini Murcielago LP640 Roadster he is getting later this summer. "I think with training, I'm a little more equipped to drive the car," he says.

For auto makers, the horsepower binge is continuing to accelerate. Even in an era of high gas prices, some like Audi and Lexus are building or testing new supercar designs. The 2007 Chevrolet Corvette Z06 packs 505 horsepower and Ford recently introduced a $41,000 Mustang with 500 horsepower.

There's no sign people are less interested in speeding, either. Movies like "The Fast and the Furious" and "Redline" have glamourized the notion of driving fast on public roads while drivers have been using sites like YouTube to post videos of themselves making flamboyant maneuvers. Mix in the growing number of supercars, their soaring horsepower and the increasing number of states raising speed limits and "we have almost the perfect storm going on here," says Adrian Lund, president of the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety.

Standing in his garage on a Sunday morning last month, Mr. Almada pulls out what's left of his beloved Porsche Carrera GT: one severed headlight and one rear-wheel tire and brake assembly. Finally, from a shelf he built to hold surfboards, he pulls down his last keepsake, the car's badly scraped carbon-fiber wing. He stares at it for a few moments, then gently lays it down. "It's like the memento of a family member who passed away," he says.

[pwd72s]

Nothing really new here. Back in the 60's, Bill Cosby made a comedy album: "200 M.P.H.". The title track is a funnier than hell account of he ordering a "special" 427 Cobra from Carrol Shelby.

Bill Cosby must have more sense than today's "supercar" buyers.
The track ends with Cosby, after taking one drive, handing the keys back, and saying: "Take this car and give it to George Wallace!"

[svandamme]

they crashed supercars in the old days too
Lamborghini Miura's and so forth regulary smacked off some mountainous road going to and from Italy or the French Riviera

you're popular , rich, and fashionable : you get a hot piece of machinery and occasionally arrive at your destination... cause either the car breaks down , or you break down the car...

oh well, **** happens, when your poor
**** happens less often when rich, but when it does, it happens faster....

[onewhippedpuppy]

Paging Ralph Nader, Ralph Nader, please report to this thread..........

Really, is the WSJ that hard up for news?

[tabs]

What does anybody need to go 200 MPH for...why does anyone need to go 120 MPH....There is a sucker born every minute.

[svandamme]

so what is your top speed tabs?
and i don't mean at the buffet.

[TerryH]

The super-rich are outdistancing themselves from most of us at a phenomal rate. Things like purses and accesories are going for over a million dollars now. They don't care how many cars they wreck.

Like the moron that wants to go 200 on a public freeway. Hope he only kills himself.

[svandamme]

Originally posted by TerryH
[B]The super-rich are outdistancing themselves from most of us at a phenomal rate. Things like purses and accesories are going for over a million dollars now. They don't care how many cars they wreck.

22 grand for a special cat

http://www.lifestylepets.com/index.html

[Steve PH]

Originally posted by svandamme
22 grand for a special cat

http://www.lifestylepets.com/index.html

Yes but how many of these special cats will end up in spectacular crashes?

[svandamme]

well, considering that rich poofs have wood floors, with good wax
and kitty cats like to have their little outbursts of 11 0'clock "activity"
i'de say a lot!

[Hugh R]

Nick Cage told me the other day that he loves his CGT over the McLaren SLR he just sold.

[kaisen]

From what I've read, Nicholas Cage isn't just a poseur he actually drives and enjoys his automobiles. They aren't just an accessory to him.

Paris Hilton + McLaren SLR= Ridicule

[Steve PH]

Paris Hilton + McLaren SLR= Brittany Spears with no panties!

[well, considering that rich poofs have wood floors, with good wax
and kitty cats like to have their little outbursts of 11 0'clock "activity"
i'de say a lot!]

What do you think claws were invented for?!

[svandamme]

claws don't grab on waxed hardwood...

[Steve PH]

Damn!

[svandamme]

i know, coz mine smacks into something just about 3 times per evening...
funny as hell , watching tv, or on the pc... hear him coming with a high speed run for whatever get's is tiny little brain fired up at 11h... then you hear the claws scratch followed by a *thud* and then a high speed run off to the other room again...

i don't have real hardwood floor though, just cheap fake laminated crap that cleans well and doesn't wear out easely

[grudk]

I think we are approaching the end of supercar popularity cycle, akin to the demise of the musclecars in the early 70s. While you could argue that gas prices were the cause of the demise of musclecars, it was really a shift in public opinion (this only in part due to gas prices)

There was an interesting quote in 'CAR' magazine a couple months back, to the effect that 'supercars will increasingly be seen as excessive, antisocial and in poor taste'

Do I want one? I wouldn't kick one out of bed, but I agree with that statement.

[svandamme]

those who drive em don't care if they're excessive , antisocial or poor taste...coz either they are indeed excessive, antisocial, and full of poor taste, or they are car nuts who will drive the snot out of them and worked to hard to deny themsalves this pleasure

to the latter i say , by all means drive the snot out of them, that's what they're there for

[grudk]

I think the number of true 'enthusiasts' buying supercars is limited -- maybe 10%. Most are poseurs looking for a trophy, or to impress a potential trophy wife/girlfriend. If you go to most Ferrari events, that's pretty clear. The crashes in the article seem to bear that out, since their car control skills seem limited. Very different crowd at a POC event than Ferrari club

Regardless, I think overall public opinion is changing, and potential supercar buyers will be affected. If it's not 'cool,' 90% won't buy