How is Peyton Manning considered the best QB of all time?

[pwd72s]

Otto Graham...

[stevej37]

After watching tonites AFC Div game...Tom Brady...no question about it.

[pwd72s]

I wasn't kidding...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Otto_Graham

[KFC911]

Originally Posted by stevej37

After watching tonites AFC Div game...Tom Brady...no question about it.

In my lifetime, I've always thought Montana, followed very closely by Brady and a couple of others...we've seen some great ones!

Now Montana and Brady both share my vote as "the best" jmho....Peyton's not even in the discssion...but he didn't suck

[stevej37]

Originally Posted by pwd72s

Otto Graham...

Brady's career passing pct. is better...and almost three times as many career yards as Otto's

[pwd72s]

Tough to compare different eras...fewer games, different styles of play, etc. So, okay..whoever you like. Besides, Brady has the hottest wife. That alone makes him the best ever, right?

[Crowbob]

Originally Posted by stevej37

After watching tonites AFC Div game...Tom Brady...no question about it.

Yep. How many dropped passes were there? That certainly would negatively skew the numbers. And the passes that were legitimately out of reach were only out of reach by inches. I cringed a few times when Brady threw the ball--until the receiver caught it!

Also, the Pats receivers are by far the best at running consistent and precise routes. Brady doesn't even have to see where they are unless they're lying on the turf. In addition, the secondary and especially the tertiary receivers must have been coached over and over that they had better keep their eyes open because that ball may be in their faces at any time.