Oban or Cardhu

[yellowperil]

For a coworker, whom I like, as a Xmas gift. It's between the two above mentioned
scotches. (Or others).

I'm a non drinker, the price is not a factor, and this for a seasoned scotch drinker.

I have never tasted scotch, so I'm a rookie at this.

There seems to be shelves and shelves of Glen this or Glen that, so I wanted to get something a bit different. IYKWIM

[HardDrive]

No help on the the Cardhu. Oban is certainly a fine gift.

[vash]

i am liking this McCallan 15 year. i think its a small cask or something.

DARK blue box. it is very good.

[oldE]

Dennis,
I would go with the Cardhu.
Single malts are very subjective.
If he doesn't like it, send it to me.

Best
Les

[yellowperil]

Originally Posted by oldE

Dennis,
I would go with the Cardhu.
Single malts are very subjective.
If he doesn't like it, send it to me.

Best
Les

OK, Thanks Les, it's as good as done.

[HardDrive]

Now I'm curious. Never had Cardhu.

[yellowperil]

I chose the Cardhu, seemed to review better than the Oban, but as I said in my first post I don't partake so maybe someone here could give us a Pelican review., Thanks guys

[ZOO]

Originally Posted by yellowperil

I chose the Cardhu, seemed to review better than the Oban, but as I said in my first post I don't partake so maybe someone here could give us a Pelican review., Thanks guys

If they are a true enthusiast, it won't matter at all. They will appreciate either. I may love my E46 M3, but I surely wouldn't turn my nose up at a Cayman S.

[yellowperil]

Originally Posted by ZOO

If they are a true enthusiast, it won't matter at all. They will appreciate either. I may love my E46 M3, but I surely wouldn't turn my nose up at a Cayman S.

Sound reasoning, that's why I wanted to get a scotch that might be new to him. Thanks