Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/)
-   Porsche 911 Technical Forum (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/porsche-911-technical-forum/)
-   -   A/C Reverse The Gases in Early Model 911's (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/porsche-911-technical-forum/858116-c-reverse-gases-early-model-911s.html)

kenikh 04-11-2015 08:55 PM

Ronknees a lot of things... But a liar??? Come on dude.

Ronnie's.930 04-11-2015 09:01 PM

^^^^ Ha! Hilarious - bet some of the folks here in the "non-turbo-911" forum are wondering about that "Ronknees" reference!

And watch it, bro, or I just might assemble a "party kit" picture post with your name on it . . . instead of Paul's!!! :D

kenikh 04-11-2015 09:10 PM

LOL! Back to the regularly scheduled broadcast...

wwest 04-11-2015 09:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ronnie's.930 (Post 8572548)
One thing I want to mention about the various vent temp pictures I've posted (which Bob is already aware of); those were originally not taken to post in a Pelican thread, but were taken to send to Bob and Eric early-ish last summer when I had completed some major, custom changes to my a/c system, was really happy with the results and wanted to share it with them (with my usual "getcha suuummm" commentary, of course). In fact, I sent them details and pictures of the work for about a month as it was taking place - including my several eff ups along the way. In other words, and as Bob mentioned, the pictures are not staged and I have no reason to lie about anything here.

I agree that the pictures are not staged.

But they do represent a practical impossibility.

Would you put a glass water in your freezer and expect it not to freeze...?

Yes, your freezer produces a lot more COLD but the physics are the same.

It might take a long time but on a hot and humid day such as is often encountered in your area an evaporator operating at sub-freezing levels WILL FREEZE UP!

There is a solution, one that most heat pumps operating in space heating mode use.

They use 2 heat sensing elements. One of those elements(A) is located nearest to the point on the EVAPORATER/(condenser) that is expected to freeze initially, near the TXV outlet, say. The other(B) is located mid-point in the EVAPORATOR/(condenser).

As the EVAPORATOR/(condenser) CHILLS both sensors will indicate a declining temperature.

Ice will act as a insulate, so, once the sensor near the inlet(A) stops falling in temperature vs the mid-point sensor, ice has begun to form around and the EVAPORATOR/(condenser) must be put through a reverse cycle, DEFROST the EVAPORATOR/(condenser).

If you even have a chance to see one in operation, during the relatively brief reverse/defrost cycle, it looks as if the heat pump has caught fire, heavy plumes of vapor rising into he air.

This is what bothers me about Charlie's refrigerant charge method, change to get the lowest possible vent temps, oftentimes sub-freezing temperatures.

But.

That would mean that the thermostatic control switch MUST be tightly calibrated. Calibrated such that on the average evaporator operating temperature must be above 32dF.

So now you have a significantly undercharged system that is not fully capable of combating a full heat load.

wwest 04-11-2015 09:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KelogGes (Post 8572690)
this thread is a perfect place to finally put a stop to you trolls that ruin every single a/c thread anyone starts here regardless of the subject matter and its been going on for years here

about 1/2 of you on here are already here posting your destructive crap

I made this tread for exposing trolls that ruin all the A/C threads regardless of subject, inducing all those I never go in to

To the people reading this but don't post here, I know you know what I am talking about

None poster I am sorry if I have ever offended you in anyway with my attitude, its been caused mostly by my disgust from the trolls that are here in the A/C threads that have an agenda to disrupt ruin

Yes, PERFECT, indeed.

You could squelch me by simply supplying before and after data indicating your reverse flow technique yields an improvement in our factory A/C performance.

You keep suggesting that some interested DIY'er try it in order to prove YOU correct.

But most DIY'er are bright enough to see the illogic in your idea.

Now that's true BS!

KelogGes 04-11-2015 09:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kenikh (Post 8572814)
Ronknees a lot of things... But a liar??? Come on dude.


kenikh
I don't generally call someone this but in this case I felt it appropriate and warranted

On An automobile this is impossible

He kept repeatedly showing a handheld gun showing this, said repeatedly his a/c system does not freeze up at all at, with air vents he shows a hand gun showing this 29 degree temperature and states he does this for long periods of time

This is A LIE

on earth this is thermodynamically impossible without freezing up the evaporator and stopping function under the laws of thermodynamics

wwest 04-11-2015 09:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaveMcKenz (Post 8572129)
OK Reid, I am starting to see your process. You dealt with condenser cooling capacity by sending hot gas to the front condenser first. You juiced up that heat exchanger by using PFC and a massive blower. That is a crucial idea. That is what Porsche did on the 964. It worked so well that they eliminated the rear lid condenser completely. I now understand why adding Spal fans to the rear lid seen unnecessary to you. If your front condenser is that good, who needs more rear condenser power.
Many of us who have preserved the stock layout have tried to juice it up with other choices. Wwest and I have increased the air flow over the rear condenser. Griff has added a rear fender condenser/fan. These are all ways of upgrading condenser capacity. Yours is a good way, but it is not the only good way.
If I was dealing with a clean sheet design, I would probably got the 964/993 route. Your solution is really a variant of that. There is no need for only one design to be OK.
Dave

"massive blower"

Dave, you need to look back at the blower picture he represented that he used in the initial "reverse the gasses" work.

Ronnie's.930 04-11-2015 09:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KelogGes (Post 8572860)
kenikh
I don't generally call someone this but in this case I felt it appropriate

Hubris + envy + self doubt = making a fool of one's self!

KelogGes 04-11-2015 10:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ronnie's.930 (Post 8572871)
Hubris + envy + self doubt = making a fool of one's self!

you are a Liar!!!
FOR WHATEVER REASON

KelogGes 04-11-2015 10:48 PM

29 degree vent temps and no freezing up is a lie

Oh Haha 04-12-2015 05:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KelogGes (Post 8572911)
29 degree vent temps and no freezing up is a lie

Ok, NOW I see why you question Ronnie's claims. Your explanation of why helped me understand but why call him a liar? To me, that is just the wrong tactic to take in trying to convince a group that your way is better.

I don't mean to sound like Dr.Phil.

Obviously, you are passionate about your work and that's good.

I'm stepping out of the thread. I wish you the best.

KelogGes 04-12-2015 06:37 AM

Solar Impulse 2 Airplane First Flight - Maiden Flight
 
<iframe width="640" height="360" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/yUpyuORoB8o?feature=player_detailpage" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>



<iframe width="640" height="360" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/oNMBPJpaimc?feature=player_detailpage" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

KelogGes 04-12-2015 07:29 AM

A/C Reverse The Gases in Early Model 911's
 
The TAN SWAN

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1428846943.jpg


The BLACK SWAN


http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1428847165.jpg



http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1428848800.jpg


http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1428848882.jpg


R134A 0.95 lbs of refrigerant total used


http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1428443176.jpg


http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1428851014.jpg


PROVEN TRUTH !!!

wwest 04-12-2015 08:11 AM

Speaking of sub-freezing temperatures....

You still haven't explained those negative PSI readings on the suction side along with decent high side PSI indications.

I've explained how sub-freezing vent temperature "snapshot" guage readings can be had without anyone lying...

Your turn... SmileWavy

Ronnie's.930 04-12-2015 09:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oh Haha (Post 8572998)
. . . but why call him a liar?

That's hubris & envy working away at Reid's delicate ego. I've demonstrated that his many years worth of boasts about superior products and methods, and his bashings of obsolete technologies and ideas, are unfounded, and his reaction to said exposure is to lash out.

KelogGes 04-12-2015 10:11 AM

Prove Me Wrong

wwest 04-12-2015 10:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KelogGes (Post 8573330)
Prove Me Wrong

NO! We're going to take it for granted that you're the one wrong since there is no existing logic to warrant a DIY'ers, or anyone's research into your invention.

Why not a start..

Explain why you think your "reverse the flow" idea will improve the A/C performance of our A/C systems.

wwest 04-12-2015 10:39 AM

Archimedes UNDERSTOOD what made the water rise in his bath....

Do you UNDERSTAND why your idea would improve our A/C..??

DaveMcKenz 04-12-2015 10:47 AM

I agree that we need credibility for the Reverse idea. I really don't care WHY anyone thinks it should or shouldn't work better than stock. Reid had an idea, he tested it, and thought it worked very well. I wish Reid would provide some of his observations on cooling performance on the day he first tried the idea. He must have seen lower pressures or lower vent temps or something. I'm the kind of guy who drives around with a thermometer in my a/c vent. I know when something is wrong. I bet he saw something that made him think he had found an improvement. He may not know why it works. If it really works, we can figure out why later. Either way. He says it works, so either take him at his word and try it. Maybe it will work. Remember, it might not work, and that's the risk you take.
Take care,
Dave

KelogGes 04-12-2015 11:12 AM

Thanks Dave as always for YOUR open minded insight

wwest 04-12-2015 11:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaveMcKenz (Post 8573365)
I agree that we need credibility for the Reverse idea. I really don't care WHY anyone thinks it should or shouldn't work better than stock. Reid had an idea, he tested it, and thought it worked very well. I wish Reid would provide some of his observations on cooling performance on the day he first tried the idea. He must have seen lower pressures or lower vent temps or something. I'm the kind of guy who drives around with a thermometer in my a/c vent. I know when something is wrong. I bet he saw something that made him think he had found an improvement. He may not know why it works. If it really works, we can figure out why later. Either way. He says it works, so either take him at his word and try it. Maybe it will work. Remember, it might not work, and that's the risk you take.
Take care,
Dave

KeloGes says he did the "reverse the flow" retrofit/conversion for at least 2 clients.

Can you imagine ANYONE committing the shop time & expense without a solidly based sales spiel?

Not exactly a try it, you'll like it type of salesmanship one could put over.

Or was he his own "client"..?

Or did the 2 conversions as free "gift" as her seems to have wont to do.

DaveMcKenz 04-12-2015 12:02 PM

I think he had an idea, and tried it out on client #1. It seemed to work so he used it on client #2. Since he was installing full systems, not that much extra to Reverse condenser order. I am certain he is convinced that it works well. No real before and after, but he is happy with the after results.
I think that is all we are going to get. So if someone is doing a full install, he might file this idea away and try it. Seems like 20 feet of hose and 4 fittings. Seems like pretty easy to undo it if needed.
Until then we have Reid's word and impression of success.
Dave

SilberUrS6 04-12-2015 12:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KelogGes (Post 8572860)
kenikh
I don't generally call someone this but in this case I felt it appropriate and warranted

On An automobile this is impossible

He kept repeatedly showing a handheld gun showing this, said repeatedly his a/c system does not freeze up at all at, with air vents he shows a hand gun showing this 29 degree temperature and states he does this for long periods of time

This is A LIE

on earth this is thermodynamically impossible without freezing up the evaporator and stopping function under the laws of thermodynamics

Well, Reid, it seems that a lot of stupid has built up in Florida. Do you know the boiling point of R134a? Would it surprise you if I told you that it is a lot lower than 0* C? A LOT lower. In fact, it is -26.3*C. So, despite your hilariously incorrect assertions otherwise, it is very possible to have vent temps lower than 0*C. Not only that, I know for a fact that these cars can make them, because I saw it repeatedly on my car. But I live in a very low humidity area, so I don't have to worry about evap freeze up. Since the system is in recirc mode, it is possible to have extended periods of sub-freezing dry air coming out of the vents.

Your lack of science knowledge puts into question your ability to engineer anything. I absolutely think there is a liar in this thread, but it certainly isn't Ronnie.

SilberUrS6 04-12-2015 12:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaveMcKenz (Post 8573441)
I think that is all we are going to get. So if someone is doing a full install, he might file this idea away and try it. Seems like 20 feet of hose and 4 fittings. Seems like pretty easy to undo it if needed.
Until then we have Reid's word and impression of success.
Dave

I think you are correct. Unfortunately, Reid doesn't have any credibility, so his repeated assertions carry zero weight. I wouldn't replumb my system unless I knew there would be real and tangible benefits to doing so. I would need more than the ravings of some self-important internet loudmouth. Well, I actually believe Ronnie, so I guess I don't need too much more.

SilberUrS6 04-12-2015 12:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KelogGes (Post 8572690)
this thread is a perfect place to finally put a stop to you trolls that ruin every single a/c thread anyone starts here regardless of the subject matter and its been going on for years here

I'm glad you're finally going to stop posting here, Reid. Your disruptive nature does nothing to improve the technical discussions on 911 AC.

wwest 04-12-2015 12:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SilberUrS6 (Post 8573459)
Well, Reid, it seems that a lot of stupid has built up in Florida. Do you know the boiling point of R134a? Would it surprise you if I told you that it is a lot lower than 0* C? A LOT lower. In fact, it is -26.3*C. So, despite your hilariously incorrect assertions otherwise, it is very possible to have vent temps lower than 0*C.

No one is arguing otherwise.

Not only that, I know for a fact that these cars can make them, because I saw it repeatedly on my car. But I live in a very low humidity area, so I don't have to worry about evap freeze up. Since the system is in recirc mode, it is possible to have extended periods of sub-freezing dry air coming out of the vents.

That's only if you, and your passenger(s) hold your breath and don't perspire for an "extended" period.

Your lack of science knowledge puts into question your ability to engineer anything. I absolutely think there is a liar in this thread, but it certainly isn't Ronnie.

Low humidity or no, eventually you will need turn down the "cold", the problem is knowing when.

Ronnie's.930 04-12-2015 12:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SilberUrS6 (Post 8573461)
I would need more than the ravings of some self-important internet loudmouth. Well, I actually believe Ronnie, so I guess I don't need too much more.

You, Sir, are in need of about 25 of these - prepare thy buttocks accordingly!!!

http://www.sherv.net/cm/emoticons/fi...ss-kicking.gif

Oh Haha 04-12-2015 12:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ronnie's.930 (Post 8573480)
You, Sir, are in need of about 25 of these - prepare thy buttocks accordingly!!!

http://www.sherv.net/cm/emoticons/fi...ss-kicking.gif

Because he believes you? :D

Sorry,came in for lunch and saw the update to this.

allaircooled 04-12-2015 01:12 PM

This thread is beyond stupid at this point. I'm just going to go water the plants sitting in back of my Targa/greenhouse and enjoy this Florida heat.

Ronnie's.930 04-12-2015 01:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oh Haha (Post 8573483)
Because he believes you? :D

Ha! No, Eric's cheeks earned a battering for the thinly veiled, pimp-slap he delivered to me in that thar post of his! :D

Ronnie's.930 04-12-2015 01:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by allaircooled (Post 8573517)
This thread is beyond stupid at this point. I'm just going to go water the plants sitting in back of my Targa/greenhouse . . .

These?!?!?!

http://www.featurepics.com/FI/Thumb3...ro-1260470.jpg

KelogGes 04-12-2015 02:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaveMcKenz (Post 8573441)
I think he had an idea, and tried it out on client #1. It seemed to work so he used it on client #2. Since he was installing full systems, not that much extra to Reverse condenser order. I am certain he is convinced that it works well. No real before and after, but he is happy with the after results.
I think that is all we are going to get. So if someone is doing a full install, he might file this idea away and try it. Seems like 20 feet of hose and 4 fittings. Seems like pretty easy to undo it if needed.
Until then we have Reid's word and impression of success.
Dave


BLACK SWAN
Client One HAD first test, test 1 was everything temporary

Test 1 went beyond excellently good temporary hoses and fittings were removed

Test 2 same clients 911, full install of everything
Followed by a week or so of testing in all types of driving situations ensued
Results WoW it not only worked, it worked WoW
Cllient very happy took delivery

6 months later Client 1 brought back in a/c warm,; Investigation discovered very slow hose leak. Hose was properly repaired, A/C recharged
Further testing ensued, results were WoW Yahoo during South Florida's HIGHEST temperature ever recorded 95 degrees ambient in extremely high humidity cabin vent
temps 30s degree's NO EVAPORATOR Freezing

BLACK SWAN Client one

Owner Extremely happy, has had back for about 2 years since original reverse the gas's install to say the least

Bob Kontak 04-12-2015 02:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KelogGes (Post 8572677)
maybe I should start following you and your Posts: 8,492 around?

I'll chill for a while. Fair enough.

wwest 04-12-2015 02:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KelogGes (Post 8573578)
BLACK SWAN
Client One HAD first test, test 1 was everything temporary

Test 1 went beyond excellently good temporary hoses and fittings were removed

Test 2 same clients 911, full install of everything
Followed by a week or so of testing in all types of driving situations ensued
Results WoW it not only worked, it worked WoW
Cllient very happy took delivery

6 months later Client 1 brought back in a/c warm,; Investigation discovered very slow hose leak. Hose was properly repaired, A/C recharged
Further testing ensued, results were WoW Yahoo during South Florida's HIGHEST temperature ever recorded 95 degrees ambient in extremely high humidity cabin vent
temps 30s degree's NO EVAPORATOR Freezing

BLACK SWAN Client one

Owner Extremely happy, has had back for about 2 years since original reverse the gas's install to say the least

Have you finally come to the realization that you're beating a DEAD horse.??

" works good ", not BETTER, but only good...!

Do I notice a trend here?

You're no longer touting this as an improvement?

Bold by wwest, text by KeloGes.

wwest 04-12-2015 02:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KelogGes (Post 8553618)
This 911 I call THE BLACK SWAN GETS 37 F degrees average vent temps at @ 95 F degrees using my custom designed PFC's (without freezing)

The owner is extremely happy to say the least!

It uses only 0.95 lbs R134A refrigerant

This test was accomplished using a couple of pieces of hose fittings and hose clamps

All the existing hose was only disconnected and left in place until the next day so the shop owner could see how well the test worked

He liked MY INVENTION so well it was completed the next day using the new invention!
He has done several 911's since The Black Swan using my invention for his clients

Why not have the shop owner vouchsafe for your invention...?

KelogGes 04-12-2015 06:05 PM

A/C TEST RESULTS 3 WENT GREAT as expected!“reversing the gas’s”
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by KelogGes (Post 8573578)
BLACK SWAN
Client One HAD first test, test 1 was everything temporary

Test 1 went beyond excellently good temporary hoses and fittings were removed

Test 2 same clients 911, full install of everything
Followed by a week or so of testing in all types of driving situations ensued
Results WoW it not only worked, it worked WoW
Cllient very happy took delivery

6 months later Client 1 brought back in a/c warm,; Investigation discovered very slow hose leak. Hose was properly repaired, A/C recharged
Further testing ensued, results were WoW Yahoo during South Florida's HIGHEST temperature ever recorded 95 degrees ambient in extremely high humidity cabin vent
temps 30s degree's NO EVAPORATOR Freezing

BLACK SWAN Client one

Owner Extremely happy, has had back for about 2 years since original reverse the gas's install to say the least


Test III The TAN Swan

The TAN Swan was a very complicated A/C project in every way possible
For this 911 I redesigned the whole A/C system into NEW TECHNOLOGY, and it took several months to do, not days or weeks; I am talking about everything, not just this or that component.

Regardless the gases for the A/C system are controlled and metered by a VOV valve and a thermostat instead of a thermal expansion valve, it has my front and rear PFC’s, The Front PFC heat exchange is by a very large proprietary high CFM blower, Rear Sealed into the Deck Lid PFC is cooled by the engine fan

And of Course “reversing the gas’s”

The A/C TEST RESULTS WENT GREAT as expected!

This 911 easily gets A/C vent temps in the 30s @ 92 degree’s ambient even with high humidity and DOES NOT FREEZE UP; the engine oil temperature change is negligible temperature rise when the A/C is turned on our off with this discovery installed!

The owner is very happy with the results to say the least
The Tan Swans owner has had it back now for about a year since reversing the gas's was installed as part of his complete A/C being replaced with a my technology A/C system


I think that as information about my discovery of “reversing the gas’s” goes out to the world for Free, you will soon see 911 early model owners worldwide switching to this discovery if they use A/C; only time will tell?

Reid Kelly

KelogGes 04-12-2015 06:31 PM

The only thing missing on Test III The TAN Swan new technology a/c system
was digital control

I finally have that NOW too for what I will be doing in the future

crownarch 04-12-2015 07:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KelogGes (Post 8573830)
Test III The TAN Swan
The Front PFC heat exchange is by a very large proprietary high CFM blower, Rear Sealed into the Deck Lid PFC is cooled by the engine fan

I don't understand how you can claim this a "large proprietary high CFM blower" when it is sold by several SPAL distributers available to the general public and for your information you are not the first to use it.

KelogGes 04-13-2015 05:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by crownarch (Post 8573943)
I don't understand how you can claim this a "large proprietary high CFM blower" when it is sold by several SPAL distributers available to the general public and for your information you are not the first to use it.

This blower did not come from from a distributor it came from the manufacture engineering team

I am required to say it is proprietary as part of the sales agreement

wwest 04-13-2015 07:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KelogGes (Post 8574271)
This blower did not come from from a distributor it came from the manufacture engineering team

I am required to say it is proprietary as part of the sales agreement



There's a KelogGes equivalent in the Spal supply chain...???


I never knew that....!


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 02:25 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.